UK government debunks ten top myths for wind power

LONDON, England, August 24, 2005 (Refocus Weekly)

Windfarms in the United Kingdom have not been associated with any major adverse effects on birds, according to a new government internet site.

The Department of Trade & Industry has posted a site with an explanation of the top ten myths for wind turbines in England, quoting a 2004 pamphlet from the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds that no windfarm has been associated with major adverse effects on the avian population. “By far the biggest threat to UK bird populations is climate change, which is mitigated by renewables such as wind,” it adds.

Environmental assessments are required as part of the planning process, to ensure that windfarms are properly sited and configured in relation to bird movements, and these assessments have improved the understanding of bird ecology, further helping conservation efforts, it notes.

On the myth that ‘turbines are taking over the countryside,’ the are 1,120 turbines in 90 locations, and generating 10% of electricity from renewables by 2010 could mean an increase by one and half times the current number, it states. Less than 1/20,000th of the country (a total of 800 to 1,200 hectares) would be used for foundations and access roads, and the land between turbines can still be used for farming or natural habitat.

Not only are windfarms not unpopular but “research suggests quite the reverse,” with 90% of the public believing the government should encourage the use of renewable energy and 80% supporting government plans to significantly increase turbine installations. Approval ratings exceed 80% among people already living within 5 km of a windfarm.

Wind generation produces no emissions, harmful pollutants or waste products and, in 25 years of operation, the 68,000 turbines around the world have had no significant reports of health issues. The DTI has commissioned an independent study in response to public concerns about low frequency noise but vibration levels 100 m from turbines are a factor of 10 lower than the safety requirements for modern laboratories, it adds.

Windfarms do not devastate house prices, and a study by the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors suggests that windfarms have no lasting impact on house prices. Local house prices recover from any initial impact once a windfarm has been operating for two years, and “people promoting fears of falling prices risk making them self-fulfilling.”

Many windfarms are tourist attractions, with 30,000 visitors to the new Scroby Sands offshore facility in one year, and 90% of tourists in Scotland saying windfarms made no difference to enjoyment of their holiday. Twice as many would return to an area because of a wind farm than would stay away, the site quotes MORI Social Research.

A single 1.8 MW turbine can produce enough power for 1,000 homes, and existing windfarms generate power for half a million homes. The average UK windfarm will pay back the energy used in its manufacture within five months, more quickly than coal and nuclear plants, and will repay this energy 50 times over its lifetime.

“Ministers have made it clear that windfarms should only be located in the appropriate place and that local concerns should be listened to,” and all proposals are subject to a strict planning process that addresses environmental, visual and community impacts. Local planning authorities consider onshore proposals up to 50 MW and they can ask for an independent public inquiry if they object to applications over 50 MW. About one third of all applications are refused, the site explains.

The government has committed £500 million to develop longer-term renewables, such as offshore wind, wave and tidal, solar, biomass and community projects, but “onshore wind is currently the most economically viable renewables technology with scope for expansion, but it will increasingly operate as part of a renewables mix as other technologies come on line,” the site explains. Britain is the world’s second-largest offshore wind generator and plans for additional offshore facilities represent the world’s largest expansion of renewable energy.


Click here for more info...