by Tom Parfitt
02-06-05
China encouraged its giant bears to mate with "Panda porn". Sri Lanka pays fishermen to protect rare sea turtles. And the Dominican Republic has a parrot team dedicated to saving the Sisserou parrot. All over the world, governments strive to preserve "flagship species" that are pushed into service as symbols of national pride.
So why is Russia building a $ 12 bn oil pipeline through the habitat of the
world's rarest big cat?
With its long, slender legs and shaggy coat, the Amur leopard is a predator that stalks the frozen forests of far eastern Russia. Naturalists say its beauty and endangered status -- there are only 30 or 40 left in the wild -- make it an ideal candidate to be a flagship. But Moscow seems deaf to environmentalists' protests that a trans-Siberian oil pipeline planned to run straight through the leopards' last wild haven could wipe them out.
The 2,600-mile pipeline -- intended to supply oil to Japan -- was to have run
from the tip of Lake Baikal to the Pacific port of Nakhodka. But an abrupt
announcement late last year made clear that a minor diversion would take the
route straight through the leopards' haven. Campaigners in Vladivostok say the
decision by the state-owned pipeline monopoly, Transneft, is
"catastrophic".
Construction begins soon, and the pipeline will pass through the border zone
of the Unesco-designated Kedrovaya Pad biosphere reserve on the Pacific coast,
where the cats live, at a pristine bay near Vladivostok, called Perevoznaya.
Cynics have speculated that local politicians in the Far East, who approved the
route, have snapped up land near the bay and aim to benefit from contracts for
construction of an oil terminal and port services funded by Japanese soft loans.
"Like a lot of Russia's ambitious projects, this pipeline plan is largely
motivated by bureaucrats who are sure of a slice of the profits," says
Alexei Yaroshenko, of Greenpeace in Moscow.
Sergei Darkin, governor of Primorye, the territory where the leopards live, denies accusations that he could benefit from kickbacks if construction contracts go to his associates.
The plight of the leopards is being seen as a test case for Russia, where the
environment is often trampled in a rush for commercial profit. Opponents say the
pipeline will not only disrupt the leopards but tear through a unique ecosystem
that supports rare and endangered species. Kedrovaya Pad is a richly forested
valley home to Chinese sparrow hawks and Hodgson's hawk eagles.
While the western end of the pipeline may not be finished for several years, a new railway to carry oil along the same route will cause equal destruction until it is completed.
"All the disturbance -- the smells, the machinery, the swathe cut through
their woodland -- will drive the leopards out of their habitat," says
Vitaly Gorokhov, head of Ecoyuris, a group of lawyers fighting the plans.
The Amur leopard is the northern most of the eight leopard sub-species, and
lives only in a small corner of the Far East near theSino-Russian border. It
feeds on roe and sika deer, as well as hares and badgers. There are about 100 of
the leopards in captivity for breeding purposes, but Kedrovaya Pad is their last
wild habitat. Experts say that, if driven away, the leopards will be forced into
terrain where there is no prey to feed on, or towards densely populated areas of
China, where the animals are hunted for use in medicines.
Transneft appears unrepentant. Challenged this spring, Transneft president Simyon Vainshtok said: "We are willing to start a dialogue with all stakeholders; we will talk to every leopard and shrimp in the bay."
Yet Transneft has refused to publish an environmental impact assessment and
gives every sign of pushing ahead with the project.
Ecologists say the fact that a pipeline is even being considered demonstrates how far Russia is willing to milk its natural resources for profit. Priorities in Primorye became clear when the regional hunting inspectorate approved the Perevoznya route.
"The inspectorate is entitled to financial compensation for the ecological
damage caused by disrupting the leopards," says Gorokhov, of Ecoyuris. The
damage was calculated according to the estimated (illegal) sale value of the
cats' skins.
"Of course it was better to have $ 100,000 in their hands right now than to
have a bunch of leopards alive in 10 years' time," said Gorokhov.
"That's how nature conservation works in Russia."
Activists in the Far East believe that they can still force a change in the route. Transneft's plans have attracted prominent critics, including the president of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Yuri Osipov, and President Putin's chief of staff, Dmitry Medvedev. He wrote to prime minister Mikhail Fradkov suggesting that the pipeline should stick to the original route.
Sarah Christie, of the London Zoological Society, who coordinates an Amur
leopard breeding programme, said there was still time to pull back from the
brink.
"We don't oppose Russia developing its natural resources," she said.
"We are just against this disastrous choice of terminal location."
Source: The Guardian