Dutch Sea Masters Reach
Out to U.S. after Katrina
September 21, 2005 — By Carmel Crimmins, Reuters
AMSTERDAM — The Netherlands' history is
the tale of an endless battle against the sea.
Now, the low-lying country wants to share its experiences with U.S. regions
hit by Hurricane Katrina.
Famed for clawing back land from an encroaching sea and building one of the
world's most formidable flood defense systems, the Netherlands is sending
experts to the U.S. Gulf Coast to help clean up after Katrina.
The category 4 storm slammed into the U.S. southern coast late last month
leaving nearly 900 people dead and devastating New Orleans.
The Dutch Transport and Water Affairs Ministry said it had sent a team of
water pumping experts to Pointe a la Hache, south of New Orleans, to help
get rid of the water. They plan to stay for a month, but could remain longer
if needed.
The Netherlands, much of which lies below sea level, suffered a similar
calamity 52 years ago when hurricane-force winds and an exceptionally high
tide breached the famed Dutch dikes in more than 450 places along the
southwestern coastline.
More than 1,800 people were killed, many as they slept.
After "The Misery of 1953," the worst flood in modern Dutch history, the
country embarked on a major overhaul of its defense systems. Under the Delta
Project, huge dikes were built and a complex system of floodgates created to
keep the sea at bay.
"We are really safe," Jan Kroos, head of the Netherlands' Storm Surge
Warning Service, told Reuters, adding that people from his office would
travel to New Orleans within a month to share their experiences with U.S.
officials.
However, Hurricane Katrina has prompted the Dutch government to review its
emergency plans in case of floods, and some experts say the country remains
vulnerable.
"The Netherlands is not yet Delta safe. Fifteen percent of our primary dike
and dune system still does not meet the Delta (project) requirements and for
35 percent we are not so sure," Marcel Stive, a coastal water expert, told
Dutch television.
SAFE?
For tiny Netherlands, the battle to keep out the sea is a matter of
survival. More than half its landmass lies below sea level and the
Netherlands -- its name means "Low Lands" -- is also one of the most densely
populated countries in the world.
Kroos admitted that his country's famed dikes would not have been able to
withstand Katrina, but says such a storm would only hit the temperate
Netherlands once in a million years.
"New Orleans lies in a subtropical area and the wind speeds that can happen
there are much higher than could happen here."
Professor Bart Schultz, a Dutch expert on water management, also pointed out
that New Orleans' defenses were much weaker.
"The safety level of the dikes in New Orleans is much lower, substantially
lower than the safety level in our dikes," he said, estimating the risk of
failure of New Orleans' dikes at 1 percent per year.
While the Dutch use multiple dikes, New Orleans had just one line of defense
on each side of the city. Schultz also argued that prevention was better
than a cure.
"If you see now what the United States government allocates for disaster
relief, that is at least 10 times the money (that would have been) needed to
take the measures before," he said.
The Netherlands' Delta Project started in 1958 and created a defensive flood
barrier capable of withstanding the kind of storm that only happens once in
10,000 years, experts say.
They raised the dikes, which now loom as much as 40 feet above the churning
sea, and created a system of floodgates that close when the weather turns
violent.
Stive says that 50 years on, these measures may no longer be good enough.
"We're 50 years further on, our economic growth has been double what was
expected, so 50 years on you can say first we should meet the Delta norms
and then ask whether our insurance premiums -- our dikes -- are high
enough."
RAIN AND RIVERS
In recent years, heavy rains and swollen rivers rather than surging seas
have posed the biggest threat to the Netherlands, famed for its
water-pumping windmills.
In 1995, melt water from the mountainous heartland of Europe and extremely
heavy rainfall combined to burst the banks of the Rhine and Maas rivers
leading to the evacuation of more than 200,000 people in the Netherlands.
The Dutch government drafted a Delta project that would involve giving major
rivers greater freedom to spill out across some parts of their traditional
floodplains while the height of the dikes controlling them would be
increased elsewhere.
The battle to keep the Netherlands dry is unlikely to get any easier. United
Nations reports say rising temperatures could trigger more storms and floods
and melt icecaps, raising sea levels by up to 3 feet by the end of the 21st
century.
"We have calculated the change in temperatures caused by climate change and
have provided for a 50-centimeter increase in sea level," said Kroos.
The daily reality of battling the sea may have made the Dutch world leaders
at flood prevention but some disaster experts say it may also have blinded
them to other dangers.
A heat wave in 2003 killed as many as 1,500 people but unlike in France,
where the government has since spent hundreds of millions of euros updating
its health system to prevent a repeat of the 15,000 deaths it suffered, the
Dutch authorities have only put some tips on the Internet.
"The sense of urgency is not felt in the Netherlands," said Madeleen Helmer,
head of the Red Cross/Red Crescent center on climate change and disaster
preparedness.
Source: Reuters |