Practical Steps For A Greener Birmingham is a detailed set of recommendations
which Friends of the Earth say would make life better for the people of
Birmingham, improve the local environment, and demonstrate a responsible
attitude to global environmental concerns, as well as save money and resources
and create jobs. As well as approaching the parties directly, Birmingham FoE is encouraging
local people to set their candidates the Doorstep Challenge -will prospective
councilors support six green pledges (see panel) and, assuming they are elected,
commit to getting all six passed through the City Council in the next two years? At the heart of Friends of the Earth's vision for sustainable resource
management, is the concept of doing more with less. They say political parties
must take the lead in challenging our prevailing 'consumption culture', where
natural resources and the environment's capacity to absorb waste and pollution
are assumed to be inexhaustible. Expanding on the ideas in the six points, spokesman Andy Pryke said: 'Doing
more with less is not the same as doing less, doing worse or doing without.
Efficiency does not mean curtailment, discomfort or privation. Being less
wasteful will allow us to do better with less. 'Why build a new reservoir if we could reduce the excess water being flushed
down our toilets or leaking from taps? Why build new nuclear or fossil-fuelled
power stations when energy efficient light bulbs can do the same job and save
people money?' The group wants to introduce a city-wide home and community composting scheme
and a scheme for neighbourhood swap shops where people could trade unwanted
household and garden items without cash. This would ease the pressure on the
waste stream in the critical area of difficult-to-recycle materials such as
furniture, provide incentives for business to set up a plastics recycling plant
on Brownfield land like the Delleve plant in Stratford-upon-Avon. They also want to make City Council grants available for the establishment of
a nappy laundry service to reduce that voluminous source of household waste
-disposable nappies. FoE does not consider incineration to be an acceptable alternative to a
proper waste minimisation strategy, said Andy Pryke. 'Incineration generates
more energy than dumping waste, but much less than would be saved by recycling.
Recycling plastic bottles uses eight times less energy than producing new
plastic. What's more, incinerators release toxic fumes into the air. ' According
to FoE, Birmingham collects 450,000 tonnes of domestic waste each year, but has
signed a contract to deliver over 90 per cent of it to the Tyseley incinerator
company, Tyseley Waste Disposal (TWD). ' Government inspectors have severely
criticised the financial cost to the city, and the overall costs are rising,'
said Dr Pryke. FoE is recommending that, at no stage between now and 2019, should the
council increase the capacity of the Tyseley Incinerator. They should make
public the whole contract between the City Council and Tyseley Waste Disposal
Ltd in order that an open and transparent re-negotiation of the contract with
the incinerator company can take place. Recycling is very popular with the public, but Birmingham's poor recycling
record is an embarrassment, said Dr Pryke. 'The City Council faces the
possibility of large fines if it does not meet its recycling targets of 17 per
cent by 2003/4 and 18 per cent by 2004/ 5.' FoE says the city should aim to
provide a doorstep recycling service for five recyclables for all households by
2005 and by 2010 have increased the number of recyclables collected from two to
eight. 'The council should also support the development of regional recycling
processing facilities, ensuring the growth and jobs created by recycling are
delivered locally,' said Dr Pryke. FoE want all parties to commit to strengthening Birmingham's local economies
at appropriate scales so that, depending on the type of goods or services,
everything is produced and delivered as locally as possible and that local
services are protected. Said Dr Pryke, 'In addition, it would be a relatively simple matter for the
City Council to source recognised fair trade products such as fruit, tea and
coffee.' FoE is urging support for the Sustainable Communities Bill, which would make
local authorities free to support local economic, environmental and social
sustainability, and commit national government to supporting local decisions to
do so. On transport the recommendations are: Set targets for zero traffic growth by
2008 with the eventual goal of an absolute reduction in traffic volumes by 2031. Road maintenance procedures that consider whether the road could be narrowed
or verges and paths widened, cycle lanes implemented, or additional trees
planted; Set a 20mph speed limit on all residential roads; Aim to increase cycling to 10 per cent of all trips by 2008; Aim to make walking a first choice for local journeys; Real priority for on-street Metro lines over the private car and integration
of the Metro with bus and rail both physically and in terms of fares. Existing
railway lines should not be converted to Metro use, these should be retained as
part of the heavy rail network; The early introduction of road user charging on a local level. But, more
importantly, the City Council should support in principle the introduction by
2008 of a national road user charge based on satellite tracking and variable
charges depending upon time of day, public transport provision along a corridor,
orbital journeys, and the rural/urban issues. A radical redevelopment of Birmingham New Street station is a national and
regional priority. Now is the time to agree a set of desired outcomes for the
station and its immediate surroundings. On congestion, said Dr Pryke, Birmingham should sign up to European In Town
Without My Car Day 2004 as well as backing or providing car sharing schemes,
involve local people in developing and compiling maps of car-free routes for
walking and cycling within their ward, with an action plan to improve and extend
these routes. 'We should also set and monitor targets for reducing the number of heavy
lorries on roads,' said Dr Pryke, who suggested a ban on heavy articulated
(38-tonne plus) lorries from unsuitable local roads and to confine them to trunk
roads, as well as the creation of rail freight transhipment depots in the inner
city area to reduce the number of heavy articulated lorries entering the city. 'We should also promote the use of canals for freight and ensure that
industrial developments adjacent to railway lines are actively facilitated to
make use of this facility for their freight transport where appropriate.' He said everyone must recognise the environmentally and socially damaging
effects of aviation on the city. FoE wants candidates to oppose the second runway at Birmingham International
Airport and further reject any proposals for extension of the current runway, to
negotiate restrictions on night flying arrivals, and to investigate the
possibility of Council Tax reductions for residents affected by aircraft noise
under the flight path and near the airport. FoE wants the City Council to provide opportunities for the development of
local renewable energy generation and to cut City Council operations' energy use
from 2000 levels by 20 per cent by 2010, and prepare a plan to address the
causes and potential effects of climate change. 'We should also monitor city-wide CO2 output and commit to meeting the
standards required to conform with the Kyoto Protocol,' said Dr Pryke. FoE wants all parties to commit to breaking the vicious circle of fuel
poverty, whereby people cannot afford adequate heating for their homes owing to
poor insulation and inefficient heating systems. Ensuring the terms of the Warm Homes Act, that no household need suffer fuel
poverty by 2011, are met earlier than that date in Birmingham is a key FoE
recommendation. 'We must also develop an energy efficiency strategy which reduces energy
usage from 2000 levels by 20 per cent by 2010 and address the chronic energy
inefficiency of City Council buildings by, for example, providing timers on
wasteful immersion heaters. Better energy efficiency leads to both savings on
energy bills and a more comfortable working environment, ' said Dr Pryke. He also urged the development of a pilot green energy building in the City
Centre in Digbeth around the Allison Street/Bordesley Street junction to include
solar and wind technologies by 2005. 'Sustainable food and farming practices should be a key objective for any
local authority, even that of a big city like Birmingham,' said Dr Pryke. 'In
particular, a commitment to local procurement, protecting the City's allotments,
and acquiring GM-free status should form the basis of the City Council's
policy.' 'We should procure locally for schools, meals on wheels, and city catering,'
he said, and he also urged continued support and development for the farmers'
market 'We think we should also apply to the Secretary of State to use European law
to prevent GM crops from being grown anywhere in the City or on Council-owned
land,' he said. They also want candidates to commit to organic management of allotments,
parks, etc. For example, stop spraying weeds out on residential (and other)
streets. He said we should clearly identify and itemise the Nature Conservation Policy
Group's annual expenditure on nature conservation and the natural environment,
and also choose species that encourage wildlife and mitigate pollution. It was also essential to ensure that the Eastside City Park, if built, is not
a 'green desert', he said. On planning, FoE want to keep greenfield sites green while making better use
of existing derelict land and buildings. In addition, the conspicuous absence of
green space from the City's Capital of Culture bid suggests that Birmingham
needs to re-think its approach to this subject, he said. FoE wants candidates to insist that all developments above a sensible minimum
size are fully and adequately environmentally assessed, and have a net positive
environmental impact and to ensure that all new civic buildings have in-built
environmentally friendly features. Another key FoE planning recommendation is the provision of more affordable
housing. On open spaces the ideas are: Incorporate ecological principles into the planning, design and management of
open spaces; Encourage community participation and consultation in the development of open
spaces; Encourage a more holistic planning approach that considers open spaces
alongside buildings rather than simply regarding them as left over pieces of
land. Commit to achieving the accessible natural green space targets in both the
Nature Conservation Strategy and Regional Planning Guidance; Ensure that Birmingham planners apply in full to all relevant development
proposals the recommended changes in respect to green space and nature
conservation contained within the Planning Inspector's report on the UDP;
lCommit to more public (particularly green) spaces in the next UDP/Community
Strategy; Ensure that the 'Fringe Belt' is recognised in the current UDP; Recognise that green space includes water both still and flowing in streams
and ponds, boggy areas and urban water courses. Said Dr Pryke: 'The city's drainage is being compromised by the growth of
hard surfaces. With little 'blotting paper' land left, rain water pours
torrentially into the roads causing flood damage and hazard to the population.
The run-off concrete water courses produced to solve this problem are adding to
the proliferation of hard surfaces and urban ugliness.' In view of this the FoE manifesto is recommending support for sustainable
urban drainage systems (SUDS) and to ensure that they are part and parcel of
development plans and approvals. lAs part of our preview of the elections next week, we will be publishing
statements from the main parties contesting the European seats. DOORSTEP CHALLENGE 1. GM crops and Food Apply to the Secretary of State to use European law to
prevent GM crops from being grown anywhere in the City or on Council-owned land. 2. Waste and Recycling Provide a weekly doorstep recycling collection of five
materials and make public the whole contract between the City Council and
Tyseley Waste Disposal Ltd, in order that an open and transparent re-negotiation
of the contract with the incinerator company can take place. 3. Sustainable Communities Support the Sustainable Communities Bill, which
would make local authorities free to support local economic, environmental and
social sustainability, and commit national government to supporting local
decisions to do so. 4. Aviation Oppose the second runway at Birmingham International Airport and
further reject any proposals for extension of the current runway. 5. Energy and Climate Change Aim to cut the City Council's energy use from
2000 levels by 20 per cent by 2010, and set a target to source renewable energy
which exceeds the regional target of 10 per cent from renewable sources by 2010. 6. Local transport Increase walking, cycling and public transport and set a
20mph speed limit on all residential roads.