ROME — Russian President Vladimir Putin's
decision to ask parliament to ratify the Kyoto Protocol should belatedly allow
the anti-global-warming treaty to come into force, but it's far from saving the
climate.
While Putin, who once joked that the chilly regions of Russia could benefit from
global warming, basks in the praise of environmentalists, climate experts say
that even with the treaty in place, the world has barely started to tackle
climate change.
Scientists say a reduction of at least 70 percent of greenhouse emissions over
this century is necessary to curb the worst effects of climate change, which
could include rising sea levels, flooding, and more frequent chaotic weather
events such as hurricanes and droughts.
The pact requires developed countries to reduce greenhouse emissions by 5.2
percent of 1990 levels by the period 2008-2012.
But without the United States — which withdrew in 2001 — and with loopholes
designed to entice Russia and Japan into ratifying, Kyoto may ultimately only
cut emissions by as little as 1 percent, some analysts say.
"The 5-percent reduction was a baby step; this is an even more baby
step," said Greenpeace's Steve Sawyer.
Galvanizing
Despite that, environmentalists are still delighted at the prospect of Russian
ratification. It will mean that nations accounting for more than 55 percent of
developed countries' carbon dioxide emissions are on board, the last requirement
for the treaty to become binding.
"I hope other nations ... will now join us in this truly global
endeavor," said Klaus Toepfer, head of the U.N. Environment Program, with a
nod to Australia and perhaps the United States.
The Australian general election next week pits an anti-Kyoto government against
a pro-Kyoto opposition.
In the United States, Democratic challenger Sen. John Kerry has said Washington
should take a lead in confronting global warming — although he also says it is
too late to sign up for Kyoto, which runs until 2012 and which the incumbent
George W. Bush withdrew from.
Kyoto's supporters say the Russian decision will also galvanize support for
sometimes painful and costly emission reduction measures in countries that were
starting to waver.
Loyola de Palacio, head of transport and energy policy at the European
Commission — which fought to keep Kyoto afloat after Bush's pullout — said
last week the E.U. should rethink its own climate policy if Russia did not
ratify.
The E.U. is set to launch the world's first international greenhouse gas
emissions trading system in January, allowing countries and firms that cannot
reach their targets to buy "credits" from neighbors who have made
greater cuts.
Russia, which will have a surplus of credits due to the collapse of much of its
Soviet-era industry since 1990, will be a net seller. The emissions trading data
firm Point Carbon said Russia could make US$10 billion in this way by 2012.
Influence
The emergence of emissions trading could be a way for the United States to
return to the global climate effort.
"The United States is in a difficult position because they are now isolated
and they don't like to sit at the back of the room and have no influence,"
said Dirk Forrister, a former U.S. climate change negotiator who is now managing
director of the emissions trading firm Natsource Europe. "There will be
increased pressure on the United States from the international community to do a
parallel program of some kind. That's true, whatever party wins the next
election."
With Kyoto now apparently brought back to life, negotiations can begin again on
new, tougher targets for after 2012 and the possibility of getting
fast-developing nations to accept curbs. Those talks could start at a U.N.
climate change meeting in Buenos Aires in December.
By 2012, environmentalists hope the United States might rejoin the system.
"We might need to change its name," said Greenpeace's Sawyer.
"People in Washington come out in a rash when you mention Kyoto."
Source: Reuters