US-Canada panel calls for tougher power grid rules

Apr 5, 2004 - Reuters Power News
Author(s): Reuters

 

(Adds government, industry reaction) By Chris Baltimore WASHINGTON, April 5 (Reuters) - A huge blackout last year that hit about 50 million people in the United States and Canada highlights the need for utilities to have mandatory standards, investigators said in a report on Monday. The Aug. 14-15 outage began in Ohio and cascaded through eight U.S. states and part of Canada on an unprecedented scale. Nearly eight months later, a U.S.-Canadian report on the probe said the blackout -- which closed airports, subways and manufacturing plants and left thousands of commuters stranded -- was largely preventable. In a 238-page final report, the investigators concluded that "compliance with reliability rules must be made mandatory with substantial penalties for non-compliance." Currently in the United States, the North American Electric Reliability Council sets voluntary standards for the industry, but no federal agency has authority to enforce them or penalize those that break them.

The report did not specify who should dole out the penalties, or what form they should take. Among the investigators' other 46 specific recommendations was a tariff-based funding mechanism for industry standard-setting boards, which would make them less financially dependent on utilities they oversee. Such rules would mean "utilities can't decide to pay or not," said Hoff Stauffer, a utility expert at Cambridge Energy Research Associates. "It's a great idea." The final report assigned no additional blame for the blackout, after an interim report last November pinned much of it on Akron, Ohio-based FirstEnergy Corp.

. The company failed to keep trees around its power lines trimmed, and did not have adequate alarms or computer equipment to flag a looming grid overload, investigators said. The utility "did not recognize or understand the deteriorating condition of its system," the report said. FirstEnergy and Midwest-area grid operators should fix such problems by June 30, 2004, the report said. By then, industry inspectors have pledged to audit readiness of 20 separate utility grids that serve 80 percent of U.S. electricity users. About 62,000 megawatts of generation went offline in the outage, shuttering factories and halting economic activity that cost U.S. companies between $4 billion and $10 billion, the report said. In Canada, gross domestic product slumped by 0.7 percent in August and 18.9 million work hours were lost, causing Ontario's manufacturing shipments to fall by C$2.3 billion. The Bush administration has been pushing for mandatory power grid reliability standards, which are part of a broad-ranging energy bill now stalled in the U.S. Senate. The administration and Republican sponsors want Congress to pass a comprehensive energy bill that includes the standards as well as billions of dollars in tax incentives to encourage more production of crude oil, natural gas and renewable energy.

"This must never happen again," Republican Sen. Pete Domenici of New Mexico said of the blackout. "The first step to preventing a future blackout is passing the energy bill." Senate Democrats, meanwhile, argue the country cannot let important reliability rules get bogged down in a fight over the broader energy bill, and have pushed for stand-alone legislation to upgrade the power grid. "Congress has a responsibility to put politics aside and do everything in its power to keep the lights on," Democratic Sen. Maria Cantwell of Washington said. (Additional reporting by Tom Doggett; Reuters messaging: chris.baltimore.reuters.c om@reuters.net; Tel: 202 898 8316))

 

 


© Copyright 2004 NetContent, Inc. Duplication and distribution restricted.