- For only the second time in twenty years U.S. electricity
generation declined last summer. Over the last two decades electrical use has
grown an average of 2.4% per year. Most of the incremental gains in
generation, if we resume the growth trend (which we should as the economy
grows and we have a more normal summer weather-wise) will be supplied from
natural gas generation units.
A new report by Stifel Nicolaus predicts higher electrical generation
utilization this summer will lead to higher natural gas prices- and
potentially to price spikes. Data released this week by the Edison Electric
Institute show that electricity generation nationwide was 6.6% higher than
the same week a year ago – Stifel predicts generation gains averaging 3%
this year.
- Bombings in Saudi Arabia and Iraq continue the trend of instability in the
Middle East, a real worry since it supplies such a large share of the
world’s crude oil. The attempted bombing of the offshore Iraq export
facilities last weekend targeted 1.9 million barrels per day of export
capacity – a sizeable amount in the world oil market. This interruption
would have had significant impacts on prices if it had been successful.
Higher crude oil prices mean that fuel switching from natural gas to oil in
the U.S. will be minimized. Since crude oil and natural gas prices correlate
relatively closely, we expect the price of both to remain above average.
- Demand for crude oil continues to grow, keeping prices strong. Note the
acompanying graph of crude oil production and consumption in India provided
by Raymond James & Associates.
Until 1990 the increase in crude oil supply and demand generally tracked
each other. Over the last decade the growth in oil demand has exceeded
domestic Indian oil production which has remained flat. This trend is
expected to continue.
Indian demand as a percentage of global demand has increased from 1.8% in
1990 to 2.8% in 2000. Raymond James expects it will hit 3.0% this year as
the Indian economy continues to expand.
- The risk premium for liquified natural gas (LNG) and crude oil is rising.
"We have begun to focus on the potential of a disastrous maritime
terrorist incident," Matthew Daley, Deputy Assistant Secretary of
State, told a security conference last month.
- Energy takeover bids last month by EnCana and Kerr-McGee indicate that
some companies in the energy sector find the future value of oil and natural
gas reserves more valuable than the market prices of the target
companies—a bullish sign for energy investors.
- Demand for crude oil from China (chart by FirstEnergy Capital Corporation)
continues to accelerate with their economy. China was an exporter of crude
oil as recently as 1991, but now it is a net importer and the level of
imports continues to grow. China now represents about 6.7% of global demand.
Recent statements from Chinese authorities claim they want to moderate
economic growth, but any measures that are implemented will take some time
to have an effect. Growth of energy intensive industries and automobile
ownership in that country are expected to continue to grow briskly.
International demands for crude oil have put upward pressures on prices.
- During the first years of the 21st century power companies have undertaken
an unprecedented expansion of electric generating capacity. One
expert noted that this building activity is “a truly historic mobilization
of construction and managerial resources to bring about this tremendous
physical plant expansion."
Worldwide capacity additions completed or scheduled from 2000 to 2006 are
estimated to be 906 gigawatts, of which 30% will be built in the United
States and around 18% will be built in China.
Due to environmental regulations in the United States most of these
facilities will utilize natural gas, although some units to be completed in
the next few years will burn coal as concerns grow about natural gas
availability and price. Natural gas generating capacity in the U.S. over the
last decade has risen much faster than those of alternative fuels, as can be
seen in the chart prepared by Stifel Nicolaus.
- The Environmental Protection Agency, under the more stringent National
Ambient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS) guidelines that were set for ozone,
announced last month that 474 counties nationwide failed ozone pollution
standards. Ozone is formed when volatile organic compounds (VOC’s) react
with nitrogen oxides (NOX) to form smog—and sunny and hot days provide the
energy.
The implication of this finding is major—all these counties now have to
adopt formal plans to reduce ozone formation by a given deadline.
Simplified, liquid fuels emit VOC’s—so adding costly controls on liquid
fuels is one way to reduce emissions and ozone formation.
Natural gas does not emit VOC’s—so using natural gas by definition
removes one of the smog precursors. The EPA restrictions will be another big
incentive for consumers and businesses in these ozone non-attainment
counties to increase their use of natural gas.
- The EPA will announce NAAQS findings on “particulates” this summer.
Smog, formed from ozone, is a source of microscopic particulates.
Regulations on particulates will also push energy consumers toward natural
gas—either by mandate or by pricing signals. Particulate standards are
also a problem for coal generating plants—and to a lesser extent diesel
engines. Again, natural gas producers will benefit from demand increases.
- Rail transportation issues, increased demand from steel makers, and coal
exports to Asia may impact U.S. electrical generation this summer by forcing
coal fired generation plants to reduce output capacity. Any coal shortfall
most likely will be made up by natural gas generating facilities.
Peabody Coal's chairman and chief executive officer remarked that the low
stockpiles could become a serious problem for the power generators because
the supply of coal is tight, and getting on-time rail delivery has also
become a problem. Train operators face service problems and delays due to
derailments. A recovering economy has boosted demand for rail service,
putting pressure on the industry. Consequently, coal power plants could find
themselves running out of coal with no quick way to restock. Some coal power
plants could have to cut back power output this summer to keep from running
out of fuel. The CEO of Massey Energy had similar comments regarding the
coal market.
And an analyst with State Street Research in a recent Wall $treet Week
interview mentioned a “possible coal shortage that we could be looking
at later this year” giving it “about a 50-50 chance of happening, and
maybe 100 percent chance of happening next year.” He concludes that
“the ramification of that is you're going to have to burn more natural gas
for making electricity if the coal plants don't have coal. And that's going
to push natural gas prices up higher than anyone would like to expect.” We
have no feel for the coal markets or the related transportation issues they
face, but the individuals making statements regarding those markets appear
credible.
- Western states are in the sixth consecutive year of drought, with portions
of the usually verdant Rockies looking more like the Mojave Desert. In what
scientists call a combination of drought cycles and global warming, nine
Western states are seeing extreme dryness. Northwest River Forecast Center,
a division of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, released
a forecast last month predicting flows to be 79% of normal from April to
September at The Dalles Dam on the California and Oregon border. Low
reservoir levels will limit hydroelectric power generation in western
states, putting more pressure on natural gas and coal units.
- The EPA is studying toxic mercury emissions from coal fired generating
units and is expected to promulgate a rule later this year that will mandate
utilities reduce such emissions under Clean Air Act provisions. Emissions
from coal fired utility plants represent the single largest unregulated
industrial source of mercury emissions in the U.S.
The technology to reduce mercury emissions is not well developed, and
whatever emission control mandates are implemented by the EPA will increase
the cost of burning coal. While a longer term issue, this is another
development that will increase the attractiveness of natural gas.
The more we look at current developments the more we are convinced that the
prices of natural gas and crude oil will remain above normal levels this summer.
We would be aggressive investors in this sector, focusing on the energy services
sector.