How deal on
energy died in last hours
Apr 12, 2006 - The Baltimore Sun
Author(s): Kelly Brewington And Andrew A. Green
Apr. 12--Just two hours remained before one of the Maryland General
Assembly's most frenetic finishes, and in the Senate lounge Sen. Thomas
M. Middleton was pleading with his exhausted Finance Committee
colleagues: Accept a plan to stagger a 72 percent rate increase for more
than a million Marylanders or return home with nothing.
But there, in the stifling lounge, the plan began to crumble.
Anxious lawmakers recalled their 1999 vote over deregulation - now a
nightmare to many - and worried that they might be about to make a
similar mistake.
"We are in trouble now because of what we did then," said Sen.
Delores G. Kelley, a Baltimore County Democrat, who has become known for
her biting remarks toward Constellation Energy in recent weeks. "I just
think this whole thing is ridiculous. We are just going along with what
they are telling us. I want to know, how does this put us in a better
place than we are now?"
It was the turning point in a day full of back-door brokering with
Constellation executives, who offered $600 million over 10 years to
blunt the rate increase for Baltimore Gas and Electric customers.
Lawmakers would allow the governor to keep the current Public Service
Commission for another year and customers would be hit with incremental
increases until January 2008, when market-rate prices would kick in. And
the plan would allow more low-income ratepayers to qualify for a program
that helps them pay for utilities.
But it would have required legislators to effectively endorse the
pending merger between Constellation Energy and FPL Group, Inc. of
Florida, something many wouldn't accept.
And it would have required them to vote immediately. With the clock
ticking inexorably toward midnight, when the session would expire, every
minute began to work against the deal.
Twelve hours earlier, the time crunch seemed to be pointing toward a
resolution. It is an old tactic in the General Assembly to hold
controversial issues to the last day, when mounting pressure gives birth
to compromise. That morning, when Constellation executives arrived for a
meeting with Gov. Robert L. Ehrlich Jr., Senate President Thomas V. Mike
Miller and House Speaker Michael E. Busch in the governor's reception
room, ready to put $600 million on the table - four times
Constellation's original offer - the strategy looked as if it was
working again.
Ehrlich bounded out of the meeting about 8:45 a.m. proclaiming
himself "very cautiously optimistic. Extremely cautiously optimistic, if
that's grammatically correct."
Busch got a mostly positive reaction when he reported the deal to the
Democratic caucus that afternoon in the House office building.
"Ultimately, it is what the best deal is for the ratepayers," he said.
But things were different in the Senate, where Miller encountered
legislators who had grown more skeptical as the session dragged on.
The morning meeting, said Middleton, was pure mayhem. Critics such as
Sen. E.J. Pipkin, an Eastern Shore Republican, and Sen. George W. Della
Jr., a Baltimore Democrat, questioned why the legislature appeared to be
giving up on overriding Ehrlich's vetoes of bills that would
reconstitute the PSC and give the legislature power over the
Constellation merger.
"A lot of it came down to the real politics of the thing: How do I
sell this?" recalled Middleton, who had a front seat in the negotiations
as chairman of the Finance Committee. "We kept going and going, and
finally, Mike said, 'We're going to go with the bill.' "
By late afternoon, communication had broken down. Miller did not
attend a scheduled 4 p.m. meeting, and instead continued to preside over
the Senate. At one point, Busch took a seat in the second- floor gallery
and watched Miller preside over debate. Miller glanced up and gave him a
nod of acknowledgment.
Around then, pessimism - and talk of a possible special legislative
session - started to creep through the State House.
"It was my understanding at that point the Senate felt there were no
more reasons to continue meeting," recalled Del. Dereck E. Davis, a
Prince George's County Democrat who is chairman of the House Economic
Matters Committee.
With Senate opposition to the plan growing about 9 p.m., House
lawmakers began crafting another version of the bill.
By 10 p.m., when Middleton called his committee meeting in the Senate
lounge, dissent was raging. At first Middleton instructed Senate
staffers to keep the lounge doors closed. But a few minutes later, they
were opened after a handful of reporters objected, saying shutting them
out was a violation of the state's open- meetings laws.
Pipkin, a former stockbroker who has emerged as one of the Assembly's
leading voices on electricity issues, objected to the plan's being
contingent upon the $11.4 billion merger between Constellation and FPL.
Pipkin peppered a committee staffer with questions as he marked up pages
of the bill with ink.
With each time-consuming question, Middleton grew impatient, barely
touching platters of fruit and vegetables on a coffee table. Across the
hall, senators were passing a flurry of last-minute legislation.
Reporters gathered behind the red leather sofas, scribbling while
photographers converged on the scene."So let me get this straight, if
this passes tonight, we are approving a merger for all practical
purposes," Pipkin snapped. "Because if we blow it up, this whole plan
goes away. There's nothing in here you can't get from a
consumer-friendly PSC."
Middleton responded that the measure offered manageable rates for the
next two years. Without it, he warned, aid to consumers could not be
guaranteed.
Some lawmakers complained they didn't have time to thoroughly
consider the 11th-hour plan, while others charged it was blatantly
unfair to customers.
"I want this legislation to work, but I can't take this bill home,"
said Sen. Lisa A. Gladden, a Baltimore Democrat. "This 72 percent never
goes away. There are additional charges that don't go away. I can't do
that. I want to take home a bill that said I tried."
Amid the fiery debate, Ehrlich's chief of staff, James C. "Chip"
DiPaula Jr., appeared in the committee room. He picked up where
Middleton left off, answering questions about the bill, and maintaining
that it was the Assembly's only choice.
"The most important consideration is that this is our best option,"
he said.
After the meeting, it looked as if the bill wouldn't get enough votes
for a favorable committee report, essentially dooming it to defeat. The
Finance Committee members filed back into the Senate chamber and took
their seats, resuming the mundane work of moving dozens of bills through
to final approval.
While senators introduced measures on the floor, Miller and Middleton
huddled at the side of the podium to count votes. At Miller's urging, a
couple of skeptics on the committee agreed to vote for the favorable
report. At 11 p.m., the bill was headed to the Senate floor.
"When you have to fall in love with something, you fall in love,"
Middleton said on his way back to the Senate floor.
It took time for the bills to be printed. When they arrived, it was
11:40. More minutes ticked by as Middleton read a summary of the bill.
He was greeted with a chorus of opposition.
"This will be a back-door approval to this merger, and I say we will
rue the day we shackled ourselves to FPL," Green said.
About that time, the House approved its version overwhelmingly in a
vote of 129-8.
Miller called for the first of two mandatory votes and got 26 yes
votes, two more than the bill would need to pass. But Senate rules
required a procedural vote to allow immediate final passage, and that
fell one vote short.
Miller returned to the other business of the Senate, speed- reading
bills to get votes recorded before the confetti that traditionally marks
the end of session dropped. But the punch was already taken out of the
session's usually jubilant final moments.
"It's a very complex bill, and we needed to spend some time on it,"
Miller said. "We'll be back, and we'll work on it again. I hope BGE and
Constellation don't give up on us."
Busch, whose chamber had stood at the ready to pass the compromise,
was much less sanguine. At 1 a.m., he walked into the press room in the
basement of the State House, exuding anger, frustration and exhaustion.
"I do not know what people were thinking that voted against this,"
Busch said. "The people expected us, Senate and House, Democrat and
Republican, to solve a problem. Solve a problem. ... And now they have
to go home and tell their constituents they get the 72 percent."
© Copyright 2006 NetContent, Inc. Duplication and
distribution restricted.Visit http://www.powermarketers.com/index.shtml
for excellent coverage on your energy news front.
|