EU acknowledges
holes in its energy policies
Jan 5, 2006 - International Herald Tribune
Author(s): Dan Bilefsky
Just hours after Russia ended a standoff with Ukraine that disrupted
gas supplies across Europe, EU officials acknowledged that the dispute
had exposed holes in the Continent's energy policy.
"Europe needs a clear and more collective policy on the security of
our energy supply," said Andris Piebalgs, the EU's energy commissioner.
"Now, powers reside at the national level and we need a Europe-wide
approach."
The 25-member EU which imports 25 percent of its gas from Russia
welcomed the agreement between Russia and Ukraine to end their gas war
and said it hoped it would assure the Union's gas supplies in the long
term.
But Piebalgs and other energy officials acknowledged that the crisis
had underscored Europe's over-dependency on energy imports, its
patchwork of contradictory national approaches and the limitations on
Brussels's ability to intervene during energy emergencies.
EU officials said the chief lesson of the standoff was that the Union
was too dependent on foreign energy sources; the European Commission
estimated that foreign sources will account for 70 percent of EU usage
by 2020.
"Dependency on Russia should be reduced," said Martin Bartenstein,
economics minister of Austria, which now holds the EU's rotating
presidency. He said energy supply and security would top the agenda at
an EU summit meeting in March. Developing a common energy policy faces
many difficulties, analysts said. Each country has its own policy on
managing and stocking energy sources, making coordination cumbersome.
During crises, countries can opt to pool energy resources, but the
European Commission has no power to force them to do so. Two years ago,
member states rejected proposals to create stores of gas across the
bloc.
William Ramsay, deputy executive director of the International Energy
Agency in Paris, warned that the lack of cohesiveness could be
debilitating if an energy shock became protracted.
"You have some countries with very liberalized markets like Britain,"
he said, "and others like Italy, France and Germany where you have
companies with dominant positions, and this asymmetry can prove
dangerous in a crisis."
Ramsay said that several European countries had large reserves in
place, but that unlike the United States, where gas stores could be
transferred easily among states, too much regulation in Europe made
national transfers difficult.
The commission said it would examine how Europe could offset
dependence on Russia by turning to suppliers like Algeria, Libya and
Nigeria and by developing alternative supply routes using pipelines from
the Middle East and Central Asia through Turkey to Austria.
Ramsay said that offsetting the EU's dependence on one energy
supplier was imperative, regardless of whether the Middle East or North
Africa could prove more politically volatile than Russia. "Five unstable
supply sources are better than depending on one unstable source of
supply," he said.
The standoff between Russia and Ukraine has prompted Britain and
Germany to consider building more nuclear power plants. But energy
experts warn that getting European countries to rally around nuclear
energy would not be easy.
EU officials said the weakness of the Union in the face of an energy
crisis was illustrated by the meeting Wednesday of the bloc's Gas
Coordination Group which consists of industry experts and convenes
during events like energy disruptions to discuss contingency plans.
People present at the meeting said the national experts were so
relieved about the 11th-hour agreement that they decided to break up the
meeting hours ahead of schedule. Jonathan Stern, director of gas
research at the Oxford Institute for Energy Studies, said he doubted the
crisis would act as a catalyst for a radical EU energy shake- up. "It
will take years," he said, "to get agreement to build the infrastructure
required for things like renewable energy or nuclear power plants, and
by then everyone will have forgotten this three- day event."
© Copyright 2006 NetContent, Inc. Duplication and
distribution restricted.Visit http://www.powermarketers.com/index.shtml
for excellent coverage on your energy news front.
|