Problems Plague Dams
in Southern New England
January 02, 2006 — By M.L. Johnson, Associated Press
SMITHFIELD, R.I. — In need of repair
for more than a decade, the Slack Reservoir Dam has been declared unsafe
and likely to fail in the event of a heavy storm.
In a worse-case scenario, 400 million gallons of water could fill the
bowl below in just 30 minutes, said Mark Barnes, president of the
association that owns and maintains the dam.
A nearby parking lot could be covered with 8 feet of water, and a wall
of water would hit 46 other businesses and homes almost immediately.
"I'm going to be a total loss if that happens," said Paul Osenkowski, a
dentist with an office across from the dam.
Thousands of New England residents live and work downstream from
centuries-old dams in need of repair, and fixing them could take years
and millions of dollars, according to interviews and a review of
government documents conducted by The Associated Press.
An AP review of documents in Rhode Island, Massachusetts and
Connecticut, as well as interviews with state officials and dam owners,
found many dams are not inspected as often as they should be and some go
years without recommended repairs.
In many cases, private owners are reluctant to shoulder repair costs or
cannot afford to do so. In others, the government has been unable to act
or unwilling to spend the money.
If the dams fail -- as nearly happened this fall when heavy rains
threatened the 173-year-old Whittenton Pond Dam in Taunton, Mass., and
forced the evacuation of 2,000 residents -- homes, businesses and lives
are at risk.
There are more than 7,000 registered dams in southern New England,
according to state records. Many date to the late 1600s, said John
Harris, director of Monadnock Institute of Nature, Place and Culture in
New Hampshire.
Dams that would likely kill someone or cause a lot of property damage if
they failed, such as the one at Slack Reservoir, are designated as "high
hazard."
Until recently, Rhode Island listed just 17 high-hazard dams. But
development has put homes downstream from dams that were once secluded.
When the state recently reexamined its dams, it found 61 -- more than
three times as many -- should be listed as high-hazard, said David Chopy,
who oversees dam inspections in Rhode Island.
Massachusetts has 320 high-hazard dams, while Connecticut has 237.
While the high-hazard label does not mean a dam is in poor condition,
many are. The three states have declared 22 high-hazard dams unsafe,
meaning they are in imminent danger of failing in a heavy storm. Fifteen
of those dams are in Connecticut, five are in Rhode Island and two are
in Massachusetts -- where dam inspectors recently suggested another
unsafe dam be added to the list.
Federal guidelines call for high-hazard dams to be inspected every two
years, but in many cases, they haven't been. Following the near-disaster
in Taunton, Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney ordered inspections of 186
high hazard dams in unsafe, poor or fair condition. Before this fall, at
least 30 of those dams hadn't been inspected in seven years and five
went longer between inspections.
None of the three states has enough inspectors to meet standards
outlined by the Association of State Dam Safety Officials. The
inspectors do their best, but they have a near impossible task, said
Sarah Mayfield, the group's spokeswoman.
"Policy-makers aren't adequately funding dam safety offices," she said.
"It's an easy issue to ignore until, of course, something goes wrong."
Money -- for inspectors and repairs -- is a universal problem. In Rhode
Island, a third of the state's high hazard dams have features that are
in poor condition. It would cost an average of $800,000 per dam to bring
them up to code, a recent DEM report said.
Seventy percent of Rhode Island's dams are privately owned, which makes
them largely ineligible for publicly funded repairs. In Massachusetts
and Connecticut, at least 90 percent of dams are private.
Publicly owned dams are not necessarily in better shape. The
Massachusetts Office of Dam Safety estimates it needs $32 million to
bring the dams owned by the state up to current safety standards. Town
and city officials say they also need money to fix dams.
It's hard to convince people to spend money on something they don't see,
said Roger Hammond, director of public works in Grafton, Mass.
"When you're asking for money for a dam versus two or three new
teachers, we're probably not going to win that one," he said.
------
Associated Press Writers Brooke Donald in Boston and Susan Haigh in
Hartford contributed to this report.
Source: Associated Press
|