Twelve States Oppose
Bush Plan to Cut Companies' Burden on Reporting Pollution
January 16, 2006 — By Michael Gormley, Associated Press
ALBANY, N.Y. — Attorneys general in
12 states said Friday that the Bush administration's plan to ease rules
on reporting legal toxin releases would compromise the public's right to
know about possible health risks in their neighborhoods.
In a letter to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, the state
officials say the proposals, which include raising some reporting
thresholds and moving from annual to biennial reports, would have the
greatest harm in low-income neighborhoods where polluting facilities are
often located.
The Bush administration proposed the changes in September as a way to
reduce the regulatory burden on companies by allowing some to use a
short form when they report their pollution to the EPA's Toxic Release
Inventory Program.
"This EPA move appears to be yet another poorly considered notion to
appease a few polluting constituents at the expense of a valuable
program," New York Attorney General Eliot Spitzer said.
Also signing the letter were the attorneys general of California,
Connecticut, Illinois, Iowa, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New
Jersey, New Mexico, Vermont and Wisconsin. All are Democrats except
Republican Kelly Ayotte of New Hampshire.
"The public has a fundamental right to know what hazardous materials
their children and families are being exposed to," said Wisconsin
Attorney General Peggy Lautenschlager.
The proposed changes, which require congressional approval, would exempt
companies from disclosing their toxic pollution on the long form if they
claim to release fewer than 5,000 pounds of a specific chemical -- the
current limit is 500 pounds -- or if they store it onsite but claim to
release "zero" amounts of the worst pollutants.
The chemicals involved include mercury, DDT, PCBs and other chemicals
that persist in the environment and work up the food chain. Companies
must report any storage of dioxin or dioxin-like compounds, even if none
are released.
The inventory program began under a 1986 community right-to-know law. If
Congress agrees, the first year the changes could be possible would be
2008.
EPA officials say communities will still know about the types of toxic
releases, but not some details about how each chemical was managed or
released.
"EPA's proposal would create incentive to accelerate environmental
protection and improve public health while maintaining competitiveness
for small businesses by setting a very high environmental bar," said
Eryn Witcher, an EPA spokeswoman. "That is, if they significantly reduce
pollution going into the environment from their facilities, they can
reduce red tape and paperwork by using a more streamlined reporting
form."
A three-part series by The Associated Press in December that analyzed
EPA air pollution data for neighborhoods nationwide underscored the need
for full and frequent disclosure, said Judith Enck, an environmental
specialist in the New York Attorney General's Office.
Source: Associated Press
|