Ministers fail
to find solution to 'Suez crisis'
Mar 14, 2006 - International Herald Tribune
Author(s): Dan Bilefsky
French and Italian finance ministers met Monday in Brussels to try to
defuse rising tensions over a contested megamerger in the energy sector
that some observers have called the "Suez crisis." But they left with
the issue unresolved. Italian officials said that Italy and France
remained divided over Suez and that there had been no fundamental change
in position.
Thierry Breton, France's finance minister, said discussions with his
Italian counterpart, Giulio Tremonti, were "constructive and upbeat."
But he emphasized that negotiations on mergers did not take place from
state to state, but between companies. Enel, Italy's dominant
electricity producer, had indicated it was prepared to make a hostile
bid for Suez if the two ministers did not resolve a dispute that has
pitted the two countries against each other and raised fears of
protectionism in the European Union. The standoff began this month when
Italy accused France of thwarting Italian plans to buy the French
utility Suez by proposing the merger of Suez with state-controlled Gaz
de France after the Italian utility Enel had signaled its interest.
But even as Breton and Tremonti met, Italy's European Union minister,
Giorgio La Malfa, urged Enel to bid for Suez, a move that would
undermine the interests of the French government.
"Takeovers are either done or not, they can't be invented so if Enel
has the possibility to do one, they should," La Malfa told Bloomberg
News.
The comments by La Malfa are the latest salvo in an escalating
slinging match between Italy and France. While Paris has strenuously
rejected Rome's allegations that it purposely set out to derail an
Italian bid for Suez, Tremonti has previously likened France's behavior
to the chain of events that led to World War I.
Enel could make an offer by the end of this week, according to a
person with direct knowledge of the situation.
Italy's annoyance at what it deems blatant economic nationalism by
France has provoked an inquiry by the European Commission.
On Monday, Austria, which holds the EU's rotating presidency, lashed
out at growing signs that countries were erecting barriers in the EU's
single market.
"We have to be clear that any government interference and
discriminatory action against foreign companies is just unacceptable,"
said Karl-Heinz Grasser, Austria's finance minister.
On Monday, Prime Minister Jose Luis Rodriguez Zapatero of Spain
claimed the EU was not succumbing to economic nationalism, saying that
moves by France and Spain to block foreign bids for domestic energy
companies were due to energy security. At a Madrid meeting with his
French counterpart, Dominique de Villepin, the two said they would work
together to create a common energy policy for Europe that gave it more
control over its energy supply. In the case of France, the tie-up
between Suez and Gaz de France was announced only after negotiations
between Enel and another French utility, Veolia Environnement, to buy
Suez were suddenly disrupted, prompting EU suspicions that the French
government derailed the Italian bid.
Enel alleges that pressure was put on Veolia to pull out of the deal
after the intervention of President Jacques Chirac of France.
© Copyright 2006 NetContent, Inc. Duplication and
distribution restricted.Visit http://www.powermarketers.com/index.shtml
for excellent coverage on your energy news front.
|