Wind integration poses no technical barriers to 20% level for utility grid

RESTON, Virginia, US, June 7, 2006 (Refocus Weekly)

The U.S. power grid can accommodate more electricity from windfarms, but “understanding and quantifying the impacts of wind plants on utility systems is a critical first step in identifying and solving problems.”

“In just five years from 2000-2005, wind energy has become a significant resource on many electric utility systems, with over 50,000 MW of nameplate capacity installed worldwide at the end of 2005,” explains the Utility Wind Integration Group in its assessment, ‘Utility Wind Integration State of the Art.’ “Wind energy is now ‘utility scale’ and can affect utility system planning and operations for both generation and transmission. The utility industry in general, and transmission system operators in particular, are beginning to take note.”

The assessment summarizes key points on wind integration and was produced with the American Public Power Association, Edison Electric Institute and National Rural Electric Cooperative Association. “The assessment does not support or recommend any particular course of action or advocate any particular policy or position on the part of APPA, EEI, or NRECA,” the document notes.

A number of steps can be taken to improve the ability to integrate increasing amounts of wind capacity on power systems, including improvements in turbine and windfarm models, improvements in windfarm operating characteristics, evaluation of wind-integration operating impacts, incorporating windfarm forecasting into utility control-room operations, making better use of physically (in contrast with contractually) available transmission capacity, upgrading and expanding transmission systems, developing well-functioning hour-ahead and day-ahead markets, adopting market rules and tariff provisions that are more appropriate to weather-driven resources, and consolidating balancing areas into larger entities or accessing a larger resource base through the use of dynamic scheduling.

“This document is a summary of the best information available from around the world on what we currently know about integrating wind power plants into electric utility systems,” says Charlie Smith of UWIG. “The message is very positive; we do not see any fundamental technical barriers at the present time to wind penetrations of up to 20% of system peak demand, which is far beyond where we are today.”

The document focuses on the impact of wind on the operating costs of conventional portions of the grid, and on wind’s impacts on electrical integrity.

“The consensus view is that wind power impacts can be managed with proper design and operation of the system,” adds Smith. “There is still a lot of work to be done to get the message across and get everyone up the learning curve, but we are well on the way.”
“On the cost side, at wind penetrations of up to 20% of system peak demand, system operating cost increases arising from wind variability and uncertainty amounted to about 10% or less of the wholesale value of the wind energy,” the report explains. “These incremental costs, which can be assigned to wind-power generators, are substantially less than imbalance penalties generally imposed” through FERC open access transmission tariffs and a variety of means (including commercially-available wind forecasting) “can be employed to reduce these costs.”

“There is evidence that with new equipment designs and proper plant engineering, system stability in response to a major plant or line outage can actually be improved by the addition of wind generation,” it notes. “Since wind is primarily an energy - not a capacity - source, no additional generation needs to be added to provide back-up capability provided that wind capacity is properly discounted in the determination of generation capacity adequacy.”

The penetration of wind generation may affect the mix and dispatch of other generation on the grid over time, since non-wind generation is needed to maintain system reliability when winds are low. “Wind generation will also provide some additional load carrying capability to meet forecasted increases in system demand,” likely to be 40% of nameplate rating.

The Utility Wind Integration Group was established in 1989 to provide a critical analysis of wind technology for utility applications, and to be a source of information on the status of wind technology and deployment.

Click here for more info...

Visit http://www.sparksdata.co.uk/refocus/ for your international energy focus!!

Refocus © Copyright 2005, Elsevier Ltd, All rights reserved.