Jolting thought:
U.S. short of electricity:
Power plant construction isn't keeping pace
with surging demand
Nov 12, 2006 - The Paducah Sun, Ky.
Author(s): Joe Walker
Nov. 12--Princeton Electric Plant Board General Manager John
Humphries was meeting with the local industrial board earlier this month
about a possible new business park tenant when the town briefly went
dark. "It turned out that TVA, which has only one line into Princeton,
made a switching error," Humphries said. "We need a more reliable power
supply that has normal and alternative feeds." Princeton Electric will
pull out of its Tennessee Valley Authority contract when it ends in late
2009 in favor of investing in the $2.5 billion Prairie State Energy
Campus plant to be open near Carbondale, Ill., in 2010 or 2011.
That venture will supply cheaper electricity for many years and
ensure that another line is built, linking the town with Kentucky
Utilities, he said. "Sixty percent of our load is industrial," Humphries
said. "We're a small town but have several factories. People don't work
when the power is off." A 2005 Kentucky Public Service Commission study
showed that Kentucky power companies "are adequately planning to serve
the needs of their customers through 2025." Peak demand is expected to
grow to an average rate of 1.7 percent, requiring about 7,000 megawatts
of additional generation by 2025 to maintain an adequate supply, the
report said.
"The bottom line from a national, regional and state perspective is
we're going to need more generation," PSC spokesman Andrew Melnykovych
said. "We in Kentucky are in a little bit better shape than a lot of
places." Nationwide, transmission systems and power plants aren't being
built fast enough to meet America's increasing demand for electricity.
Research by Federal Bank of St. Louis economist Kevin Kliesen shows
that: --About 10,000 miles of high-voltage lines will be added in the
U.S. between 2005 and 2014, a growth rate of only 0.6 percent.
Meanwhile, power sales are projected to increase by 1.75 percent
annually.
--Generating capacity needs to increase by 347 billion watts from
2005 to 2030, but 54 percent of that won't come until 2021 to 2030. Some
economists doubt that supply is keeping pace, potentially increasing the
risk of supply disruptions. "I foresee a capacity shortfall in about
2010 or 2012, and that's about the time Prairie State will come on
line," Paducah Power System General Manager Dave Clark said. "We think
we're going to have our power distribution in good shape in about five
years, cost-wise and supply-wise." PPS, which also will depart TVA in
2009, has joined Princeton Electric and other utilities investing in
Prairie State, a 1,600-megawatt coal-fired plant co-owned by Peabody and
CMS energy corporations.
Clark said Prairie State should ensure long-term supply at rates
cheaper than TVA, but he worries most about transmission. Deregulation
caused many companies not to expand grids out of fear that competitors
would "cherry pick" their more lucrative industrial and commercial
customers, he said. Deregulation also made power firms hesitant to
invest in expensive plants and lines without long-term supply contracts,
said Ken Breeden, TVA executive vice president for customer resources.
He said the cost of meeting increasingly stricter clean-air laws also
has hindered construction. Breeden said most of the newer power plants
are natural gas-fired, built during the past 15 years before gas prices
soared and used only to produce power during heavy-use periods.
Only six of TVA's 158 distributors in seven southeastern states have
given notices of seeking power elsewhere, and Breeden said he is unaware
of any others who want to leave. He said having contracts with that many
companies helps TVA's long-term planning. "Some people call it a
monopoly," he said. "I call it a relationship allowing us to hedge our
investment position. We can make decisions for large base-load
investments because we know customers will be there to pay for it." TVA
will restart a mothballed unit at its Browns Ferry Nuclear Plant in
Alabama next spring, reflecting a 2002 decision by the previous board of
directors, Breeden said.
"With today's gas prices, that was an incredibly good decision." The
unit will generate enough power to supply 650,000 homes. TVA generation
in 2008 will be 53 percent coal-fired, 40 percent from hydroelectric and
nuclear, and 7 percent from natural gas. Reliance on gas-driven
electricity is much greater than that nationwide, he said. "The peak of
the TVA system is just slightly over 32,000 megawatts, and we're asking
now what that will look like when we get to 40,000," Breeden said,
adding that the mix of various types of power plants will be adjusted
based on that planning. Nuclear plants cost the most to build but have
the cheapest fuel, he said.
The opposite is true of gas, and coal is somewhere in the middle.
Ninety-five percent of Kentucky's power is coal-fired, and the state has
the lowest electricity costs in the nation. In 2005, the average retail
rate was 4.47 cents per kilowatt-hour, 40 percent below the national
average rate of 7.52 cents. The PSC study cited uncertainties that could
affect Kentucky's long-term ability to ensure those low rates. Among the
concerns are federal policies regarding the development of regional
electricity markets and air-emission standards -- factors affecting coal
production and the price of coal.
Transmission requirements elsewhere in the nation threaten to
diminish Kentucky's control of plants built and paid for by its own
customers, the PSC said. Paducah-based Jackson Purchase Electric Corp.
-- which has the second- or third-lowest rates statewide -- is able to
offer cheap power because its supplier, Big Rivers Electric, hasn't had
to invest in a plant since 1983, said JPEC President/CEO Kelly Nuckols.
"We're very concerned with the supply-demand issue because at some point
in time it means we're facing building a new generation plant." Because
a new plant will cost three or four times as much as one built two
decades ago, "everybody's rates are going to be impacted by that," he
said.
Power company officials are generating a supply-demand white paper to
participate in a summit meeting later this month with officials of the
Governor's Office of Energy Policy, he said. Factors behind increased
power use Bigger, cooler homes -- From 1970 to 2004, the average new
home increased from 1,500 to 2,350 square feet, and the percentage of
new homes with central air conditioning rose from 34 to 90 percent.
Computer use -- One large call center reportedly uses enough electricity
to power a city of 30,000 to 40,000 people. -- Source: Federal Reserve
Bank, St. Louis
© Copyright 2006 NetContent, Inc. Duplication and
distribution restricted.Visit http://www.powermarketers.com/index.shtml
for excellent coverage on your energy news front.
|