Editor's Note: Because of the upcoming holidays, Inbox
will not appear next week. It will return to its regular
schedule beginning Thursday, Jan. 3.
Everywhere I go these days, I'm seeing green.
It's "see green, save green" at the local grocery
chain, "green" programs in my natural gas bill, even
"green" billing advantages on my bank statement.
It makes me wonder how long Americans will stay
interested in "greening" their lives if this trend in
overzealous eco-marketing continues.
Already, it seems to be becoming cliché, and green
buying practices seem to have become more of a fashion
statement and "the thing to do" than a way of life.
A search on Google recently brought up nearly 190,000
hits on the word "green."
Granted, it's also a color, but the mention of
environmentally friendly practices dominated the search
engine's return. Some of the headlines displayed included,
"Hey kids: Do you have a green grandma?", "Green wine?
I'll drink to that" and "Want to go green? Try deer
hunting first."
I scrolled through about 15 pages of Google hits and
most stories on "green" lifestyles were less than a day
old.
My cynical self makes me wonder whether that many
people are starting to care, or whether growing a green
conscience is just the "thing to do." Also, if the concern
is genuine, how much marketing can we take before we start
to tune out?
A study of United Kingdom residents shows that already
more than a quarter of Britons are suffering from
"eco-fatigue." The study found that 23 percent are bored
with eco-news, and about 18 percent exaggerate their
eco-friendliness because it is fashionable.
When certain trends become too prevalent, too, I think
skepticism of them grows.
An article in the Sydney Morning Herald has highlighted
a problem with numerous companies marketing their products
as green when they really are not. I think the more
prevalent green marketing becomes, the more wary people
will become of whether the claim is true.
I would love to buy more earth-friendly products, but
sometimes wonder whether many really are green, or whether
they just want more of my green.
A study recently conducted by the Natural Marketing
Institute and the public relations firm Porter Novelli
found Europeans are 50 percent more likely to buy green
products than Americans, but were 20 percent less likely
to pay more.
The higher "green" rate in Europe, however, seems to
come more from stricter environmental laws than
eco-marketing strategies.
Europeans have been faced with high fuel costs much
longer than we have, and overseas travelers can't help but
take notice of how many tiny cars and other fuel-efficient
vehicles they drive as a result.
I'm convinced that inundating the public with green
marketing strategies won't be nearly as effective as
consumers having to pay $3.50 per gallon for gas or deal
with other budgeting blows.
In Germany, the federal government decided to begin
paying cash incentives to residents willing to install
solar power panels on their roofs.
An article in the Daily Utah Chronicle on Germany's
plan states that now, seven years later, Germany is the
world leader in solar cell production and has created
170,000 new jobs as a result.
So while it may be believed that bombarding consumers
with the message that the benefits of green is worth it,
at the expense of their pocketbooks, it seems Americans
might be better off with more incentives and rewards for
their efforts rather than new "green" stuff to buy.
Otherwise, people might stop listening altogether,
assuming "green" is just another passing fad.
Rachael Whitcomb is
associate editor of Waste News. Past installments of this
column are collected in
the Inbox archive.
To subscribe or visit go to:
http://www.wastenews.com