Trade focuses on wild movements between crude benchmarks
 
New York (Platts)--24May2007
The controversy over the continuing fall in the value of WTI relative to 
other international benchmarks picked up further steam Thursday, as the
already wide premium that Brent is holding to WTI blew out further, and WTI
spent another day less than the value of Dubai.

     July WTI crude on the New York Mercantile Exchange settled $1.59/barrel
lower at $64.18/b, while July Brent on the IntercontinentalExchange settled
12 cents/b higher at $70.72/b, putting the July WTI-Brent spread at minus 
$6.54/b. The spread has been widening all week, from minus $3.44/b on May 18,
as the US Midwest Cushing oil hub remains glutted with supply, while North Sea
supplies have tightened.

     The initial blowout in the WTI-Brent spread was set in motion when
Valero's 170,000 b/d McKee refinery in Sunray, Texas, went offline in February
as a result of a fire. McKee is one of about 11 refineries that link into the
pipeline system that feeds into Cushing, Oklahoma, home of the NYMEX delivery
point.

     At the time, NYMEX light sweet crude futures were at a 91 cents/b premium
to Brent. The McKee refinery went into partial restart April 23, but the loss
of refiner demand over two months caused a backlog of barrels in the Midwest.

     But the new movement Thursday was driven in part by an announcement that 
McKee took a fluid catalytic cracker offline, and the concurrent planned
maintenance at ConocoPhillips' 146,000 b/d Borger, Texas, refinery, another
unit hooked into the Cushing oil system. With McKee's FCC down for about two
weeks and ConocoPhillips' Borger refinery expected to be in turnaround until
June 23, the lack of demand for crude barrels in the Midwest should contribute
to further weakness in the WTI market.

     The US Energy Information Administration reported May 23 a 900,000-barrel
build in Cushing inventories. At 27.357 million barrels, stocks at Cushing
were just 658,000 barrels below the all-time high posted the week ending April
13, causing the front of the crude futures curve to sag. July/August settled
at minus $1.45/b May 24 after settling May 23 at minus $1.25/b. 

     Brent futures continued to be supported by reduced North Sea loadings and
unrest in Nigeria. Official loading programs for North Sea grades Oseberg and
Ekofisk show June volumes down by 16%. 

     "The bullish flag on crude oil remains with the expectations of Nigerian
disruptions leading to the presidential nomination next Tuesday and will keep
the market on edge in front of a long Memorial Day weekend. But some
disruption will need to materialize by next week to bring some stress back to
the crude system," Petromatrix said in a report. 

     Meanwhile, the collapse in WTI values against benchmark Dubai prices,
following its earlier move down against Brent, is setting up an unusual crude
arbitrage: North America to Asia.

		--staff reports

     This is an excerpt. For more news, request a free trial to Platts Oilgram
News at
http://www.platts.com/Request%20More%20Information/index.xml?src=story
or subscribe now at
http://www.platts.com/infostore/product_info.php?cPath=1_29&products_id=29