Where next for oil prices as WTI climbs above $92/barrel?

 

 

October 26, 2007 - There was considerable alarm in mid-September when New York crude futures prices climbed above $80/barrel. OPEC secretary general Abdalla el-Badri, speaking three days after OPEC's September 11 meeting, which resulted in a decision to increase actual crude output by 500,000 b/d from November, said OPEC didn't believe the then-record prices would last because they were not justified by market fundamentals or any shortage of crude.

Badri attributed the price spike largely to hurricane-related supply fears in the Gulf of Mexico, an attack on a gas pipeline in Mexico and refinery problems in the United States. "We don't think about a permanent $80," he said at the time.

But prices have continued to climb, soaring above $90/b on October 19, and trading at a new record of $92.22/b on Friday.

On Thursday, after the US imposed new sanctions on Iran, US light crude futures settled above $90/b for the first time ever. Analysts now are not ruling out $100 oil.

As prices raced upwards towards $90, Badri issued a statement on October 16 expressing OPEC's concern but insisting that the market was well-supplied and that the surging prices were due more to speculators in the market than to any fundamental shortage of oil.

Falling commercial crude inventories in the US ahead of the peak winter demand season have been a key factor in driving prices towards the $92/b level, while the continuing weakness of the US dollar has also added upwards momentum.

The new $92.22/b record for US light crude came the day after Washington tightened sanctions on Iran to punish the country for its nuclear ambitions and alleged sponsorship of terrorism.

"Iran-US sanctions...that was the trigger yesterday," a London-based broker said Friday. "If you look at the sanctions in detail, though, they won't affect exports of crude. But all those words in one sentence is bullish."

Another broker said: "We thought $90 would be the lid but it has now exceeded that and where does it stop? It is above all resistance levels now. $100? It's anyone's game."

Analysts at Barclays Capital said the "confluence of strong fundamentals and a worsening geopolitical environment" had created the platform for the sharp rise in prices.

Evidence that oil balances are tight has been mounting and, with inventories low, markets are becoming increasingly uneasy about winter supply.

"As a result of this strong fundamentals backdrop, geopolitical events are exerting heightened influence on prices. The escalation of tensions between Turkey and Kurdish separatists, along with the increasingly confrontational tone over the Iranian situation--with a new set of sanctions having been imposed by the US--are certainly aiding factors behind the strong upwards momentum," they said in a report.

"OPEC's decision to raise production by 500,000 b/d effective November is also too little, in our view, to soothe current market tightness," the Barclays Capital report said.

Leo Drollas, deputy executive director at the Centre for Global Energy Studies, a London think-tank established by former Saudi Arabian oil minister Ahmed Zaki Yamani, said the world needed more OPEC oil.

"With the oil price over $90/b, it's obvious the market needs more oil, and the sooner the better," he said Friday. "Saudi Arabia has been increasing output since the summer.

Discounts for heavy crudes have been rising, but they will have to do more. If they don't, there is a danger that prices will get out of hand and damage the world economy's growth prospects through inflationary pressures."

The International Monetary Fund warned on October 17 that, against a background of limited spare oil production capacity, oil supply shocks or heightened geopolitical concerns could lead to further price spikes. Options prices, it said, suggested a one-in-six chance of prices rising above $95/barrel over the period.

The IMF said the global economy had so far been "able to absorb the sustained run-up in oil prices over the past five years without major impact," but noted that despite some expansion of OPEC production capacity and "massive" investment by Persian Gulf producers, "the overall supply response to the recent higher level of prices has been sluggish so far."

US Energy Secretary Samuel Bodman has repeated his call on OPEC and other producers to boost output to ensure that global oil demand is met, noting that while US crude stocks were currently above the five-year average, global stocks, especially those in the industrialized countries, were below historical levels.

Bodman said on Wednesday that he had been in contact with OPEC ministers and was "hopeful they will follow through" with additional supply.

OPEC heads of state will meet in Saudi Arabia on November 17-18 and a ministerial meeting is scheduled for Abu Dhabi on December 5, but the group has given no signal that it might boost output further this year.

Secretary general Badri was quoted saying Wednesday during a visit to Beijing that the group was not currently discussing another output increase.

"We have no price band or price target," the Wall Street Journal quoted Badri as saying. "If it persists for a longer period, then we start worrying. But at this time we don't know what's going to happen next month."