Solar silicon boom wanes as new plants sprout:  Analysis

 

LOS ANGELES/NEW YORK —

The mad dash to build polysilicon plants for the solar industry is beginning to slow as prices for the raw material start to retreat from their 20-fold increase in recent years.

Still, production of the material, which is used for computer chips, as well as converting sunlight into electricity inside solar cells, is likely to triple in the next three years, easing the shortage that has plagued makers of photovoltaic solar systems.

That expected increase is already pushing down prices for longer-term supply contracts, according to industry experts and is forcing some companies to rethink proposed plants.

Last week, China's Trina Solar Ltd. scrapped its plan to build a $1 billion polysilicon plant, saying it expected to buy supplies in the expanding market.

"It's hard to justify that capital expense when you are heading into a situation of oversupply," said Ted Sullivan, an analyst at Lux Research who forecasts that supplies of polysilicon will outstrip demand as soon as 2010. "It's really only a matter of time before these project financiers or solar companies really wake up and smell the coffee that it doesn't make much sense sinking $300 million into a new plant."

An oversupply of polysilicon is possible, Sullivan said, despite the rapid growth of photovoltaic solar cell production, which has been doubling about every two years to meet the growing appetite for clean sources of energy.

Lower polysilicon costs should help cushion solar makers' margins, which are expected to shrink as more production of cells and modules comes on line. That margin pressure may hurt in the coming quarters, although analysts say it will also spur demand for solar power by making it competitive with electricity from dirtier sources, such as coal-fired power plants.

"Long term that's good for the solar market ... it's ripping off the bandage, if you will," said Sullivan.

Polysilicon currently sells for $450 per kilogram or more on the spot market, while long-term contracts can drive that down to about $50 to $120/kg, according to Lux Research. Prices hit a low of about $23/kg in 2003, just before a dramatic surge in demand from both the semiconductor and solar industries.

Producers of polysilicon, which include Hemlock Semiconductor, a joint venture owned by Dow Chemical Co and Corning Inc, and South Korea's DC Chemical Co Ltd have announced plans to expand output aggressively, and solar companies, including wafer maker LDK Solar Co Ltd, have even announced their own plants.

 

SOLAR RELIEF

Although near-term prices remain high, the tide is shifting in the solar companies' favor, according to Cowen & Co analyst Rob Stone.

In 2007, he said, long-term polysilicon contracts required buyers to pay between 10 percent and 20 percent of the contract value upfront. That has now moved down to the single percentages.

"They've changed their tone and are asking less onerous terms," Stone said.

Thanks to long-term contracts, SunPower Corp said last week that its polysilicon costs in 2008 would be about 10 percent less than the previous year, but that supplies would remain tight "potentially into 2009."

Lux Research expects producers will cancel half the announced expansions that would lift worldwide capacity to 338,000 tonnes by 2010, forecasting instead that capacity that year would reach 157,000 tonnes.

That figure is more than three times the 2007 level.

Much of the shortfall will come from new Chinese polysilicon producers, according to Calyon Securities.

"A massive capacity ramp up is in the works, with some new supply coming in 2008," Calyon Securities analyst Kelly Dougherty said in a report earlier this month. "However, much is set to come from new facilities in China that are ramping at a much slower-than expected pace."

Calyon expects actual 2008 output from Chinese producers of just 2,500 tonnes -- well below the 24,760 tonnes those companies have planned for this year.

Players outside of China have also suffered production delays. Norway's Renewable Energy Corp. earlier this year said the start of a polysilicon plant in Moses Lake, Washington would be delayed by two months to late 2008, reducing the company's production target for the year. (Editing by Andre Grenon)


By: Nichola Groom and Matt Daily
 

Copyright 2008 Reuters.