N.J. Challenges Air Pollution Reporting Rule;
State Says Washington is Letting Industry Off the Hook
Feb 20 - Record, The; Bergen County, N.J.
New Jersey filed another legal challenge against federal environmental
policies Tuesday, this time questioning a new rule that gives industry more
leeway in reporting air pollution.
The state asked a federal appeals court in Washington, D.C., to review a
rule, adopted by the Environmental Protection Agency in December, that lets
factories, coal-fired power plants and other pollution sources decide when
increases in air emissions are significant enough to require detailed
record-keeping.
It also asked the EPA to reconsider the change.
The rule is dangerous, state officials said, because emission records help
regulators decide when plants are violating clean-air limits.
"What this rule does, essentially, is leave plant operators to determine for
themselves whether their emissions call for installation of new pollution
controls," Anne Milgram, New Jersey's attorney general, said in a statement.
The EPA measure, announced Dec. 14, covers hundreds of plants around the
nation. New Jersey blames many of them, especially big Midwestern coal
plants, for the smog, acid rain and mercury emissions that waft into the
state from beyond its borders. State officials have spent much of the past
seven years in court fighting various Bush administration attempts to change
the regulations governing those plants.
The administration has defended its proposals, saying they help plants
become more efficient while still protecting air quality. But the courts
have generally sided with New Jersey and other states.
The EPA did not immediately respond Tuesday to a call seeking a comment. An
industry group representing electric power plants also did not respond,
saying it had not yet seen New Jersey's court filing.
One Washington activist, however, called the December rule "a Christmas
present to smokestack industries."
"It was designed to reduce the public's ability to know if industry is
increasing its emissions," said Frank O'Donnell, president of Clean Air
Watch. "In effect, the Bush administration is saying, 'Let's trust
industry.' "
Lee Moore, a spokesman for the attorney general's office, said other states
may join New Jersey's challenge against the new rule.
***
E-mail: nussbaum@northjersey.com
(c) 2008 Record, The; Bergen County, N.J.. Provided by
ProQuest Information and Learning. All rights Reserved. |