New research shows that prairie grasses grown using only moderate
amounts of fertilizer on marginal land can produce significant amounts
of ethanol.
The five-year study of switch grass done by the University of
Nebraska and the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Agricultural Research
Service was published this week by the National Academy of Sciences.
Researcher Ken Vogel said he estimates that an acre of switch grass
would produce an average of 300 gallons of ethanol based on the study of
grass grown on marginal land on farms in Nebraska, South Dakota and
North Dakota.
An acre of corn grown in those same states produces about 350 gallons
of ethanol on average.
The latest study adds to the evidence supporting the development of
cellulosic ethanol, Renewable Fuels Association spokesman Matt Hartwig
said.
"It underscores that cellulosic ethanol production is not only
feasible, it is essential," said Hartwig, whose group represents ethanol
producers.
Nebraska Ethanol Board Projects Manager Steve Sorum said the industry
is excited about the prospects for cellulosic ethanol because the
feedstocks for it, such as switch grass, are cheaper to grow. Also, some
of the byproducts created in the process can be burned to generate
electricity.
The key will be developing an economic way to break down the cell
walls of cellulose-based fuel sources, Sorum said.
Both cellulosic and grain-based ethanol will likely be used to meet
the new federal standard for biofuel use. The energy bill Congress
passed last month requires a massive increase in the production of
ethanol to 36 billion gallons a year by 2022.
The energy bill will emphasize cellulosic ethanol, made from
feedstocks such as switch grass and wood chips, after 2015, when about
two-thirds of the nation's ethanol is supposed to come from such
non-corn sources.
Hartwig said there is general agreement that 15 billion gallons a
year is about the most ethanol that can be produced from grain with
current technology without hurting grain markets. That makes it
important to develop other sources for the renewable fuel, he said.
Vogel said comparing the amount of ethanol produced by corn with the
amount that could be produced by switch grass is a bit unfair because
the method of converting switch grass to fuel is still being perfected.
Last year, the Department of Energy announced plans to invest $385
million in six ethanol refineries across the country to jump-start
ethanol production from cellulose-based sources - a process that has not
yet proven commercially viable.
But Vogel and the other researchers did develop an estimate of how
much energy switch grass would produce based on current conversion
rates. Switch grass produces more than five times as much energy as the
amount consumed by growing the crop and converting it to ethanol,
according to the report.
Vogel, a U.S. Department of Agriculture geneticist and University of
Nebraska-Lincoln professor, said the switch grass research is the most
extensive to date. |