Neighbors at Odds Over Noise From Wind Turbines
BROWNSVILLE, Wis. -- Nov 04 - USA TODAY
Not long after the wind turbines began to spin in March near Gerry Meyer's
home, his son Robert, 13, and wife, Cheryl, complained of headaches.
They have trouble sleeping, and Cheryl Meyer, 55, sometimes feels a
fluttering in her chest. Gerry is sometimes nauseated and hears crackling.
The culprit, they say, is the whooshing sound from the five industrial wind
turbines near the 6-acre spread where they have lived for 37 years. "I don't
think anyone should have to put up with this," says Gerry Meyer, who
compares the sound to a helicopter or a jet taking off.
As more turbines are built, the noise they create is stirring debate.
Industry groups such as the American Wind Energy Association say there's no
proof they make people sick, but complaints of nausea, insomnia and other
problems have surfaced near wind farms across the USA.
Nina Pierpont, a pediatrician in Malone, N.Y., calls the ailments Wind
Turbine Syndrome and is writing a book on them. In the preface, which she
shared with USA TODAY, she says the syndrome "is an industrial plague. It is
man-made and easily fixed. Proper setbacks are the best cure."
Laurie Jodziewicz, siting manager for the American Wind Energy Association,
says there are almost 15,000 wind turbines in the USA, and most people live
near them "without incident. ... We would have heard if this was a
widespread issue."
The nearest turbine is 1,560 feet from Meyer's house. His dismay ohas made
the retired mailman, 59, an activist. He travels the state warning
communities considering wind farms to be wary.
Studies have mixed results
One of the nation's first nuisance lawsuits against a wind farm ended with
rulings in 2006 in favor of the company that developed it after landowners
near the Abilene, Texas, project objected to turbine noise.
Objections to wind farms continue to be raised:
*Pierpont's website, www.windturbinesyndrome.com, includes reports of
illness from Union, Ore.; Mars Hill, Maine; Saginaw, Texas; King City, Mo.;
and elsewhere.
Wendy Todd, who lives 2,500 feet from a turbine in Mars Hill, says she
suffers sleep deprivation, and her neighbors have headaches and dizziness.
"You just can't get used to it," she says of the noise.
*British physician Amanda Harry said in a 2007 study that people living near
turbines can experience anxiety, depression, vertigo and tinnitus.
*Mariana Alves-Pereira, a Portuguese acoustical engineer, said in a 2007
study that turbines can cause vibroacoustic disease, which can lead to
strokes and epilepsy.
A 2008 study funded by the European Union, however, found that the sound
annoys many people, but it doesn't affect health "except for the
interruption of sleep."
Some of Meyer's neighbors don't understand the fuss. People who say the
noise makes them ill are exaggerating, says Rudy Jaeger, 67, who has a
turbine on his farm. "It's no worse than traffic driving by."
Francis Ferguson, chairman of the Byron Town Board, which voted to approve
the project here, has heard talk that the sound makes people sick, but says,
"I haven't seen any documentation that it's true."
The American Wind Energy Association would like to see "a credible,
third-party" scientific study, Jodziewicz says. Setbacks are settled between
developers and communities, and there's no industry standard, she says.
Susan Dennison, spokeswoman for Invenergy, the Chicago company that built
the 86-turbine wind farm here, says it hasn't received any complaints about
health problems in the area.
The turbines here, which are 389 feet tall including blades, must be 440
feet from property lines and at least 1,000 feet from homes, she says.
Concerns over home values
Eric Rosenbloom of National Wind Watch, an information clearinghouse, says
noise and health concerns are the top issues in communities considering
them. The group recommends 1-mile setbacks from homes.
Rick James, an acoustical engineer from Okemos, Mich., suggests keeping
turbines 1 1/4 miles from homes.
That makes sense to Larry Wunch, a firefighter who lives a few miles from
the Meyers. Turbines encircle his property, and when the wind tops 15 mph,
he says, they "just scream." The closest is 1,100 feet from his house.
Wunch says he and his wife, Sharon, "have lost sleep and are irritated." He
worries his home's value has declined and says the wind farm has created
tension between opponents and those who have them on their property in
exchange for annual payments that Dennison says are about $5,000 a year.
"It's really turned our township upside down," Wunch says.
"If it's affecting your health," Meyer says, "it's hard to ignore."
(c) Copyright 2008 USA TODAY, a division of Gannett Co.
Inc. To subscribe or visit go to:
http://www.usatoday.com |