But Who Will Drive Them?
Published: January 16, 2009
The cornucopia of hybrid and electric vehicles showcased at the North
American International Auto Show this week suggests that the nation’s
automakers — domestic and transplanted — have finally acknowledged the need
to deliver the fuel-efficient cars and trucks for a future of expensive gas
and increasing environmental pressures.
But a big obstacle remains to the greening of American drivers: the price
tag. With gas prices likely to remain low as consumers grapple with
recession, drivers are going to need extra motivation to swap their gas
gluttons for the novel, environmentally friendly cars and trucks. If the
incoming Obama administration is serious about its commitment to boost the
fuel efficiency of the American fleet, it must put in place a mix of
policies, beyond tightening fuel-economy standards for carmakers, to steer
drivers to the new cars.
The price of Ford’s new hybrid Fusion sedan, estimated to travel a whopping
41 miles per gallon in the city, is expected to start at more than $27,000.
The Volt, General Motors’s high-profile plug-in car, could cost as much as
$40,000. There are cheaper paths to environmental virtue: The Toyota Prius
starts at only $22,000. And Honda’s Insight hybrid — to go on sale later
this year — is expected to cost less.
Still, with gas below $2 a gallon and recession-ravaged consumers hanging
tight to their wallets, even the cheaper hybrids have to compete with cars
that run on boring old internal combustion engines. The Prius was the flavor
of the month when gas prices soared to $4. But in December, Prius sales
plummeted 45 percent compared with the same month a year earlier — more than
the 36 percent drop in all car sales.
Do the math. At $1.66 a gallon, the average gas price assumed in the
government’s 2009 energy guide, a hybrid Toyota Camry would only save the
average driver about $250 a year in gas, compared with the regular Camry.
But the hybrid costs $7,000 more.
A hefty gas tax would, of course, produce a strong incentive for drivers to
switch to more fuel-efficient cars. But confronting a staggering economy,
the Obama administration would be right to look for other options in the
immediate future. The modest tax rebates offered to jump-start sales of
hybrids and plug-ins starting in 2005 already have been phased out for the
more popular models made by Honda and Toyota — and are slated to disappear
entirely at the end of next year.
These rebates could be extended and increased. Ideally, they would be
available to buyers of any car that achieved big improvements in energy
efficiency, not just hi-tech vehicles. Another, more aggressive option
floated last year by Alan Blinder, an economist at Princeton, would be for
the government to buy up the most polluting and gas-hogging clunkers from
American drivers and scrap them. That is an idea that has been tested in
several states.
These ideas would fit neatly into an economic stimulus strategy, the Obama
administration’s effort to save Detroit’s carmakers and its stated
environmental objectives. Just hoping that American drivers will buy the
fuel-efficient cars that the government wants Detroit to make is likely to
achieve little.
A version of this article appeared in print on January 17, 2009, on
page A24 of the New York edition.
Copyright 2009 The New York Times
Company To subscribe or visit go to:
http://www.nytimes.com |