Solar Beats Power Lines in State Poll
May 28 - Portland Press Herald
By a nearly 2-to-1 ratio, Mainers would prefer using solar panels to upgrade
the state's power grid over putting up high-voltage lines, according to a
poll released Wednesday.
Younger people and those who say they support environmental causes are most
likely to see solar energy as the answer to keeping the lights on, the poll
suggests.
The poll was released at a news conference organized by GridSolar LLC, a
Portland-based company that hopes to fill the state's future electricity
needs with acres of strategically placed solar collectors. The event was
part of a high-stakes campaign to present an alternative to Central Maine
Power Co.'s proposed $1.5 billion upgrade of the state's transmission
system.
Both proposals are in front of the Maine Public Utilities Commission.
GridSolar is trying to capitalize on popular opposition to big transmission
lines and towers, and on the growing public affection for green power, to
position itself as an innovative way to give Maine a reliable grid.
It filed a petition with the PUC last winter to become a transmission and
distribution utility, essentially competing with CMP.
The decision, expected this year, rests solely with the three PUC
commissioners. But GridSolar has mounted a publicity campaign that includes
town meetings, presentations to newspaper editorial boards and polling.
The poll was included in an omnibus survey done by a veteran pollster, Chris
Potholm. The survey of 500 residents, done in April, has a margin of error
of 4 percentage points.
Poll results had 38 percent of respondents supporting GridSolar's approach
and 20 percent backing CMP. Significantly, 42 percent said they were unsure
or had no opinion.
Dennis Bailey, president of Savvy Inc., a public relations firm that
GridSolar hired to help convey its message, said the numbers are
encouraging. Bailey is also spokesman for Rich Connor, the prospective buyer
of the Portland Press Herald/Maine Sunday Telegram.
"CMP is a household name," Bailey said. "This is like running against an
incumbent."
Although PUC proceedings aren't political campaigns, public pressure can
have an effect. Last year's highly organized opposition to the sale of
Verizon's phone lines to FairPoint Communications, for instance, led the
commission to attach stronger conditions to its approval, in Bailey's view.
Also in play: The term of the commission's chair, Sharon Reishus, expired in
March. The chair can continue to serve until reappointed, or until the
governor nominates and the Legislature confirms a new one.
Part of the strategy of GridSolar and its supporters, Bailey said, is to
push for a replacement they see as open to unconventional energy solutions.
CMP responded to the poll by saying it's not surprising that people who are
concerned about the environment favor solar power. But there's no way to
know how well respondents understood the purpose and merits of CMP's
proposal, said spokesman John Carroll.
The power company has been meeting with community leaders and editorial
boards, too. Its message is that renewable resources can make valuable
contributions, "but we don't see them as a substitution for transmission
lines," Carroll said.
The commission is reviewing CMP's proposal to build a new high- voltage
transmission line and substations through 80 communities from Orrington to
Eliot. CMP has said that power disruptions may occur in its aging system by
2012 if nothing is done to modernize lines and towers.
If approved, the upgrade will trigger one of the largest construction
projects in Maine. The four-year job, which would create an estimated 3,300
jobs at its peak, has the backing of Gov. John Baldacci.
GridSolar was formed by Richard Silkman and Mark Isaacson, partners in
Competitive Energy Services in Portland. They represent large power buyers
in energy contracts and have developed small power projects.
They want to place arrays of solar-electric panels near communities that use
lots of power. The panels would go up in 25- acre fields, initially around
the midcoast and Lewiston-Auburn. The locations would correspond with areas
that CMP has identified as being most prone to future reliability problems.
The concept, called distributed solar generation, is used in Germany.
Solar arrays would fill in local power-supply gaps on summer days, when the
sun's rays are strongest and when air conditioners are running in homes and
businesses.
The solar electricity generated during those periods would help lower future
electricity rates for residential customers, the company says.
GridSolar is proposing to build a total of 800 megawatts of solar
generation, roughly the output of the former Maine Yankee nuclear plant.
Construction would be phased over several years, to keep pace with demand. A
25-acre site could accommodate enough panels to generate about two
megawatts.
The approach is favored by two groups that were represented at Wednesday's
news conference, Opportunity Maine and the League of Young Voters. They see
the potential for more jobs over a longer time, and they like the idea of
using renewable energy close to where it's needed.
They also are strong on reducing power plant emissions.
A media campaign that taps those public desires can help raise the profile
of an unknown entity, said MaryEllen FitzGerald, president of Critical
Insights Inc., a strategic marketing firm in Portland.
CMP is well regarded in Maine, FitzGerald said, and appreciated for
restoring power after storms. But a campaign that elevates GridSolar as a
green alternative can be effective.
"There's a lot of cachet with green power now," she said.
Staff Writer Tux Turkel can be contacted at 791-6462 or at:
tturkel@pressherald.com
[Sidebar]
MORE ONLINE:
For more information, go to:
www.gridsolarme.com
www.mainepower.com
Originally published by By TUX TURKEL Staff Writer.
(c) 2009 Portland Press Herald. Provided by ProQuest LLC. All rights
Reserved. To subscribe or visit go to:
http://pressherald.mainetoday.com/ |