Arizona Corporation Commission requires 22% energy-use
cut by 2020
Jul 28 - McClatchy-Tribune Regional News - David Wichner The Arizona
Daily Star, Tucson
State regulators approved rules Tuesday requiring utilities to cut their
customers' annual energy use by at least 22 percent by 2020 -- among the
highest such standards in the nation.
The Arizona Corporation Commission approved the rules unanimously,
despite objections from utilities including Tucson Electric Power Co.
that the goal will be hard -- if not impossible -- to reach.
"It's an ambitious but achievable standard," commission Chairman Kris
Mayes said. "It flattens out the utilities' growth curve."
Mayes said there is a "huge value" just in avoiding the need to build
natural-gas power plants commonly brought on line to fill peak power
needs.
"It's effectively among the strongest energy-efficiency
standards in the country," said Jeff Schlegel, a Tucson-based
representative for the nonprofit Southwest Energy Efficiency Project.
If the 22 percent goal is reached, the rules will save Arizona
ratepayers nearly $9 billion and save Tucson ratepayers $1.4 billion in
energy costs, while the rules will create an estimated 12,000 new jobs,
Schlegel said.
The rules require regulated utility companies to design programs that
promote energy efficiency or reduce peak demand through mechanisms such
as time-of-use electric rates.
Examples of such "demand-side management" programs include
weatherization, home energy audits, promoting the use of compact
fluorescent light bulbs, and replacing home appliances with more
efficient models.
New energy-efficiency programs would be funded through an existing
demand-side management surcharge on monthly customer bills. The
surcharge currently costs the average residential TEP ratepayer 83 cents
monthly, but it could increase to cover the new energy-saving programs.
Utilities including TEP, Arizona Public Service Co. and some of the
state's electric cooperatives said they strongly support energy
efficiency but warned that the 22 percent usage reduction would be tough
to achieve.
"The goals are ambitious and they've been approved, and we're going to
work hard to achieve them in a cost-effective manner," TEP spokesman Joe
Salkowski said.
In filings leading up to Tuesday's action, TEP had filed formal
objections, known as exceptions, to the rules.
"The record does not support a 22 percent standard from the perspective
of either technical feasibility or cost-effectiveness," the company
said.
TEP also said the rules were flawed because they don't provide a
mechanism for utilities to recover revenues lost due to reduced
consumption.
An association of Arizona's member-owned electric cooperatives,
including Marana-based Trico Electric Cooperative, also had objected to
the energy-efficiency standard.
The Grand Canyon State Electric Cooperative Association said the 22
percent savings goal may not be realistic, proposing that each co-op be
allowed to file an individual plan that includes a cost-recovery
mechanism.
"We support energy efficiency and promote it, but as a co-op it's
difficult for us to do things on the scale they're asking us to do,"
Trico spokeswoman Romi Carrell Wittman said.
Arizona Public Service Co., the state's biggest power company, supports
the standard despite its challenges, the company's energy-efficiency
manager said.
"We do think it's very aggressive," APS' Jim Wontor said. "It will not
be easy to achieve, but we think it's the right strategy for our
customers."
Every other year on June 1, each utility will be required to file a plan
describing how the firm will meet the energy-efficiency standard for the
next two calendar years. The commission will review and approve the
plans and require annual progress reports.
The utilities will be required to develop programs to benefit
residential, non-residential and low-income customers, with costs for
low-income customers to be spread out among all other customer classes.
The energy-efficiency rules are headed to the Attorney General's Office
for final endorsement.
Salkowksi said TEP is concerned that it won't be able to recover its
fixed costs because of reduced power sales, noting that TEP's rates are
capped through 2012.
The energy-efficiency standards may hasten a move to restructure utility
rates to encourage conservation by "decoupling" recovery of fixed costs
from rates traditionally based on consumption.
The Corporation Commission has been holding workshops to examine
decoupling as part of rate design for future rate cases.
"We're hoping decoupling leads to a place where utilities can invest in
energy efficiency without compromising their financial stability,"
Salkowski said.
Contact Assistant Business Editor David Wichner at dwichner@azstarnet.com
or 573-4181.
(c) 2010,
McClatchy-Tribune Information Services To subscribe or visit go to:
www.mcclatchy.com/
|