Obama would end nuclear waste project in fiscal
2011
Washington (Platts)--2Feb2010/712 am EST/1212 GMT
The Obama administration followed through Monday on its commitment
to cancel a nuclear waste project in Nevada, proposing to disband the
program in its fiscal 2011 budget for the US Department of Energy.
"The administration has determined that Yucca Mountain, Nevada,
is not a workable option for a nuclear waste repository and will
discontinue the program to construct a repository at the mountain in
2010," the administration said in its fiscal 2011 budget proposal.
The administration said last year it would stop work on the
Yucca Mountain repository.
DOE would receive $98.4 million for the program in fiscal 2011,
which begins October 1, under the budget request. The request is roughly
half of the $197 million the program received this fiscal year, which
ends September 30.
DOE CFO Steve Isakowitz said Monday at a budget briefing that
$45 million of the money sought would come from nuclear energy research
and development, roughly $43.4 million from money the civilian nuclear
waste program received this fiscal year, and $10 million for program
redirection. All of the money sought would come from the Nuclear Waste
Fund, DOE said.
The US Nuclear Regulatory Commission, meanwhile, which has been
reviewing DOE's repository license application since fall 2008,
requested $10 million for its Yucca-related work in fiscal 2011. An NRC
budget document said that DOE may submit a request to the agency in 2010
to withdraw or suspend its repository license application.
"Upon the withdrawal or suspension of the licensing review, the
NRC would begin an orderly closure of the technical review and
adjudicatory activities and would document the work and insights gained
from the review," NRC said in its budget request.
Yucca Mountain, roughly 95 miles outside Las Vegas, has been
seen as a potential repository site since the 1970s. It became one of
three candidate disposal sites when Congress passed the Nuclear Waste
Policy Act of 1982. Five years later the act, as amended in 1987, named
it the country's sole candidate for a disposal facility for high-level
nuclear waste, a move that program opponents have charged was
politically driven.
DOE spent more than two decades and $9 billion on the program.
No show-stoppers were found during that time, according to DOE and the
Nuclear Waste Technical Review Board, an independent oversight panel.
But during his presidential campaign in 2008, Barack Obama
proclaimed that Yucca Mountain was not an option. Senate Majority Leader
Harry Reid of Nevada has been a fierce opponent of the Yucca Mountain
project, claiming the site is not safe.
On Monday, Reid called the administration's budget proposal
"great news because it not only prevents Nevada from becoming the
nation's nuclear dumping ground, it also protects hundreds of
communities through which the waste would have to travel to get to
Yucca."
Energy Secretary Steven Chu said Monday that DOE would file a
motion with the NRC later in the day to "stay" all Yucca Mountain
licensing activities for 30 days. NRC later confirmed it had received
the motion.
Chu said that within the next 30 days the department would move
to withdraw the repository license application that NRC began reviewing
in fall 2008. DOE said the application would be "withdrawn with
prejudice," a move that would prevent it from being considered again.
The administration would close the Office of Civilian
Radioactive Waste Management, which has overseen development of the
proposed Yucca Mountain repository and combine its responsibilities with
DOE's Office of Nuclear Energy, the budget proposal said.
Termination of the program would mean that the utility spent
fuel and DOE high-level radioactive defense waste now stored at sites in
39 states would remain there until there is a new path forward for the
waste.
Chu on Friday announced the formation of a 15-member
blue-ribbon commission that will evaluate alternatives to a Yucca
Mountain repository and submit a final report to Chu in 24 months.
Mary Olson, nuclear waste specialist with Nuclear Information
and Resource Service, said in a statement Monday that "Yucca exemplified
the failure we get when waste policy is driven by politics rather than
science."
She said the makeup of the commission "will take us all down
the same old road with money and politics in the driver's seat."
Chu did not appoint a "single nuclear power opponent--or even
mild critic--to the panel," Michael Mariotte, NIRS executive director,
said.
--Elaine Hiruo,
elaine_hiruo@platts.com
--Bill Loveless, bill_loveless@platts.com
|