Environmentalists criticize energy bill over trash
burning
Apr 30 - McClatchy-Tribune Regional News - Mary Spicuzza The Wisconsin
State Journal
Could burning trash be a part of Wisconsin's clean energy future?
Some environmentalists and legislators are urging Gov. Jim Doyle to veto
a bill they say undermines the state's renewable energy goals -- and
falsely promotes garbage as a clean technology source.
"Signing this bill will result in less renewable solar, wind and biomass
energy for Wisconsin at a time when our economy and our environment
desperately need more, not less, of these technologies to decrease our
dependence on dirty fossil fuels," a coalition of environmentalists
wrote in a letter to Doyle this week.
The bill, SB 273, would give renewable resource credits to electricity
providers who can replace power from coal, oil, natural gas or nuclear
sources with things like solar, geothermal and biomass energy. An
amendment to the bill, added by Senate Majority Leader Russ Decker,
D-Weston, and others shortly before the end of the legislative session
included power sources such as "synthetic gas created by the plasma
gasification of waste" and fuel from the "pyrolysis of organic or waste
material."
Decker could not be reached for comment.
Sen. Jeffrey Plale, D-South Milwaukee, a lead sponsor of the bill, said
critics are misrepresenting the issue. He said the bill would promote
new technologies, including a "demolecularization" process to get rid of
trash that can't be recycled. And Josh Morby, a spokesman for Alliance
Federated Energy of Milwaukee, called the critics "shortsighted."
But environmentalists, who are already fuming about the recent death of
the state's clean energy bill, which would have required 25 percent of
the state's power to come from renewable sources by 2025, say the bill
is misguided. Wisconsin's current goal is to get 10 percent of its power
from renewables by 2015.
"Not only did the Senate stop us from expanding renewable energy, we
went backwards," said Rep. Spencer Black, D-Madison.
He and Sen. Mark Miller, D-Monona, lead sponsors of the failed clean
energy legislation, and Tia Nelson, executive secretary of the Board of
Commissioners of Public Lands, are also asking the governor to veto the
bill.
Dan Kohler, director of Wisconsin Environment, said if the amended bill
becomes law "it will diminish the Governor's accomplishments on clean
energy and be a shame given his leadership" on other environmental
issues.
Groups that wrote to Doyle calling for a veto include the Sierra
Club-John Muir Chapter, Midwest Environmental Advocates, Wisconsin
Environment, Clean Wisconsin, Advocates for Renewable Energy, the
Citizens Utility Board and others.
Doyle's office didn't respond to questions Wednesday and Thursday about
whether the governor would sign the bill.
(c) 2010,
McClatchy-Tribune Information Services To subscribe or visit go to:
www.mcclatchy.com/
|