Making Waves with Tidal Energy
  August 27, 2010

Ken Silverstein
EnergyBiz Insider
Editor-in-Chief
Read Ken's Blog

Respond to the editor.

The first-ever federal license to proceed with a utility-scale tidal energy project in this country has been issued in Oregon. After an extensive permitting process, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission has given the thumbs up to Ocean Power Technologies.

Smaller such facilities are now underway. But the commercial-scale one that is to be built in Reedsport, Ore. covers a wide array of issues such as the preservation of aquatic resources, water quality and the maintenance of marine life. In the end, regulators -- who are trying to diversify the nation's energy mix with green fuels -- concluded that wave energy is a valued part of the plan and that it is more predictable than wind or solar.

"This development will help pave the way for the United States to retain a technological advantage in wave power, an advantage that has been ceded to other countries that produce solar panels and wind turbines," says George Taylor, executive chairman of Ocean Power. "Wave energy has the potential to create manufacturing jobs in America, while providing low-cost clean, environmentally benign electricity to help replace the use of fossil fuels."

The Electric Power Research Institute performed feasibility studies in this area. The Palo Alto, Calif.-based research arm of the electric utility sector said that unlike hydropower, tidal energy does not require the permanent impediment of water flow and the subsequent harm to aquatic life. Existing tidal plants, it adds, impound the water before releasing it into generators. And newer tools are even more progressive and use underwater turbines that ultimately connect to cables to transport the power.

The U.S. Department of Energy says that wave energy could eventually supply 30,000 megawatts of electricity. Right now, a number of prototypes are being tested not just in this country but also overseas in the British Isles, Italy and Portugal. Existing tidal power plants include a 240 megawatt facility in France, a 20 megawatt plant in Nova Scotia and a 0.5 megawatt one in Russia.

As for the one in Oregon: Ocean Power wants to install 10 buoys that can generate 150 kilowatts of electricity in the Pacific Ocean, and then connect them to a transmission system that would feed power to citizens of the state. Development would be phased in over time so as to protect "ocean resources and stakeholder interests."

Because the technologies to achieve such a vision are relatively untested and because the federal government wants to foster sustainable energy forms, the company was able to recently win a $1.5 million grant from the U.S. Department of Energy. Two years earlier, it had gotten a $2 million grant for the same Oregon project.

"Because the systems do not require dams, impoundments or other major civil works, they cause minimal public and environmental impact and have lower upfront capital costs, an aspect that makes them especially suitable for use in developing countries," says Verdant Power, another company in the business of wave energy.

Choppy Waters

As the world's largest solar collectors, oceans in particular generate thermal energy. Waves are unending and therefore have the ability to produce power around the clock. Moreover, seawater is 832 times as dense as air, providing a six mile-per-hour ocean current with more kinetic energy than a 217 mile per hour wind, say experts.

Verdant, for example, has a test going in New York's East River using underwater turbines. ConEdison will use the resulting electricity for a local grocery store and underground parking garage.

To bring the general idea into the mainstream, however, scientists and engineers must still show that their work can be done on a large-scale basis. And rough waters lay ahead. Environmentally, tidal power plants can impede sea life migration and can affect local ecosystems. The optimal solution, says the Energy Department, is to carefully select sites that preserve scenic shorelines.

Economically, there are also barriers. Operating tidal plants is reasonable. But building and maintaining them is expensive. Therefore, the return on investment takes a long time. It is furthermore problematic when it comes to getting the power to shore. While more predictable than current prevalent green sources, wave energy is still not as dependable as fossil-fired or nuclear generation.

But if the existing commercial and pilot projects prove out, then it would encourage other developers to get on board. With more experience and with the mass production of the essential technologies, prices would come down. At the same time, newer technologies that are around today are less problematic and don't block migratory paths.

Indeed, many places around the United States are conducive to energy derived from the waves or tides. In fact, anywhere that has major rivers or strong ocean currents is a candidate. That includes areas in the Pacific Northwest, the California coastline and Alaska. The Northeast and other parts of the Atlantic shore are also possibilities.

"This is an exciting time for our state and I look forward to continuing to foster this new industry in Oregon in a way that is sensitive to marine habitat and continues to value this important resource for Oregon's fishermen," says Oregon's Governor Ted Kulongoski.

Renewable energy will gain increasing traction in both domestic and global markets. And while wind and solar are the most advanced forms, wave and tidal energy are beginning to make waves. The key now is to prove that the power source is viable by getting a few of those facilities up and running.

 

Energy Central

Copyright © 1996-2010 by CyberTech, Inc. All rights reserved.

To subscribe or visit go to:  http://www.energycentral.com