ANALYSIS: Saudi Arabia buffeted by Bahrain riots, Yemen unrest
Dubai (Platts)--18Feb2011/501 am EST/1001 GMT
Saudi Arabia, the oil Goliath which holds in its hands the only
significant spare production capacity that can meet any potential global
supply disruption, has been besieged by bloody riots in neighboring
Bahrain and a growing anti-government protest south of its border in
Yemen.
All this while King Abdullah is out of the country recuperating in
Morocco from two rounds of back surgery that some say have weakened the
octogenarian monarch who many consider as a stabilizing forces in a
tumultuous Middle East now that ally Hosni Mubarak is out of power in
Egypt.
Sources close to the Saudi al-Saud royal family say the king is
preparing to return to Riyadh within days though it is not yet clear if
King Abdullah is fully recovered or whether the events of recent days
hastened his decision.
Since the start of the January 25 popular uprising in Egypt,
international crude oil benchmark Brent crude oil prices have been
oscillating at levels just above $100/barrel, rising at one point to
highs above $104/b as more Middle Eastern and North African countries
such as Libya and Algeria, both OPEC oil producers serving the European
and US oil markets, joined their Egyptian and Tunisian brethren in
demanding regime change.
The small kingdom of Bahrain is one of the few Arab states in the
Persian Gulf region that has no oil wealth to speak of, relying on its
Saudi neighbor for crude oil from a shared oil field.
The anger that has spurred bloody confrontations in Manama, which lies
across the Persian Gulf from leading Shi'ite power Iran and is a
regional banking center, is led by the majority Shi'ite Muslim
population railing against the Sunni Muslim royals in charge of
government.
The tiny island state is also host to the US Fifth Fleet, which leads
the international naval force policing the Persian Gulf waterway and the
Strait of Hormuz, through which some 40% of total tradable oil is
shipped to world markets from Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Qatar, the UAE, Iran
and Iraq.
Bahrain, which is bracing for angry protests on Friday, borders Saudi
Arabia's Eastern Province, the kingdom's main oil producing hub and home
to its disenfranchised minority Shi'ites, many of whom have family ties
to Bahrainis across the causeway that spans a narrow strip of the
Persian Gulf.
King Abdullah's departure in late December for surgery in the US for a
herniated back and a haematoma had already revived concerns about a
potential power struggle in the world's energy powerhouse.
The king's half-brother Sultan and next in line Prince Nayef are both in
their 80s, and a succession beyond the immediate future uncertain in a
country that holds one fifth of global oil reserves.
Fear of contagion to other Arab states once Egypt's Mubarak bowed to
popular pressure and relinquished power after 30 years at the helm of
the Arab world's most influential nation has propped up oil prices in
recent weeks.
ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM
But analysts say it would be simplistic to assume that a common template
applies to Persian Gulf states, where oil wealth and generous state
subsidies tends to act as a buffer against popular discontent.
Thomas Lippman of the Washington-based Council on Foreign Relations said
in an interview February 17 posted on the Saudi-US Relations Information
Service that there are differences between Egypt and Saudi Arabia, the
US's strongest regional allies.
"In fact, the situation in Saudi Arabia is more different from the
situation in Egypt than it is alike. First, King Abdullah is personally
popular, unlike Egypt's ousted President Hosni Mubarak. Second, the
Al-Saud family is widely understood to be -- and accepted as --
legitimate rulers of the kingdom," said Lippman.
"Furthermore, the Saudi regime, unlike the one in Egypt, has more than
enough money to spread around," he said, adding that the entire business
and religious establishment in Saudi Arabia is "intertwined" with and
dependent upon the ruling royal family.
King Abdullah, the world's Arab monarch, is a pragmatist and a modest
reformist, who has had to balance the demands of the conservative Wahabi
Muslim establishment in the desert kingdom, with the aspirations of
ordinary Saudi men and woman hoping for a bigger slice of the oil-based
economy.
"Abdullah has been much more forthcoming than his predecessors in making
some social, political, and professional space for women. He has
publicly curtailed the arbitrary power and the capricious behavior of
the so-called religious police, the mutaween, who are actually behavior
police," wrote Lippman, adding that the reforms, which do not amount to
any kind of popular democracy, are "top down" rather than arising from
popular unrest.
But one Saudi businessman says he can see problems ahead as more of the
kingdom's oil wealth is distributed among the many members of the vast
royal family. "There is going to be a smaller piece of the pie for
ordinary Saudis, and four or five years down the line I see trouble."
In Egypt, where a million members of the youth-led movement plan to
celebrate Mubarak's ouster a week ago today, one blogger noted that the
revolution that has inspired the wave of Arab revolts is far from over.
"But it is only the end of the beginning. What begins now is the
struggle for Egypt's future and we hope that it will be rebuilt slowly
but surely and without external interference," wrote Rosemary Sabet, a
long term British resident of Cairo who has kept a daily blog of events
there.
As Lippman noted, a "politically 'comatose' Middle East" has been
awakened by the protests that have rocked Arab capitals from Tripoli to
Sanaa. "...suddenly there is a giant elephant in the room in every Arab
capital, which is the idea that change is possible..."
--Kate Dourian,
kate_dourian@platts.com
To subscribe or visit go to:
http://www.platts.com
|