Heart Surgery in India for $1,583 Costs $106,385 in U.S.
August 14, 2013
Story at-a-glance
A coronary bypass costs over $100,000 in the US but only $1,583
in India – and efforts are underway to lower costs there to just
$800
The US spends more on health care than the next 10 biggest
spenders combined, while ranking last in terms of quality of
care among industrialized countries
About 600,000 Americans travel abroad to receive lower-cost
medical care every year, and this number is growing by about 20
percent annually
Americans are being overcharged for often sub-par medical care,
as well as given unnecessary tests and procedures alarmingly
often
Take control of your health to stay well and avoid falling
victim to the broken health-care system
By Dr. Mercola
The average cost of a coronary bypass at the Cleveland Clinic
in Ohio is $106,385. In India, you can get the same procedure
for 95,000 rupees, or $1,583, which is half the price
it cost 20 years ago. And, efforts are underway to bring the
cost down even more, to about $800, within a decade.
The lower cost is the result of one Indian heart surgeon’s
quest to make health care more affordable for India’s
population, where two-thirds live on less than $2 a day and most
pay for health care entirely out of pocket.
His efforts to drive down costs include cutting out
unnecessary pre-op testing and using Web-based computer software
as opposed to building new systems for each hospital.
Even sourcing lower-priced disposable surgical gowns and
drapes helps, showing that lower costs are not only attainable,
but that the cost-saving measures could theoretically be
duplicated in developed countries, including the US.
“The current price of everything that you see in
health care is predominantly opportunistic pricing and the
outcome of inefficiency,” Devi Shetty, the
aforementioned heart surgeon, noted.1
More Americans Are Taking Advantage of Medical Tourism
It’s because of drastic price differences like these that
many Americans – upwards of 600,000 a year – are traveling
abroad to receive medical care, a phenomenon known as ‘medical
tourism.’ These numbers are expected to grow up to 20 percent
annually,2
fueled largely by the aging Baby Boomer generation coupled with
rising health care costs in the US.
Even after factoring travel expenses, including airfare and
hotel accommodations for the patient and a guest, Americans may
still save tens of thousands of dollars depending on the type of
surgery received. According to Patients Beyond Borders, which
specializes in medical tourism, if your total quote for US
medical treatment is $6,000 or more, you’ll probably save money
by traveling abroad for your care.3
India, where patients can receive savings of up to 85 percent
on medical procedures compared to the US, remains a top medical
tourism destination, but others, such as Costa Rica, which has a
higher health system ranking than the US,4
are quickly gaining popularity.
There are certainly drawbacks to medical tourism, such as
exposure to different kinds of
superbugs and, sometimes, language barriers, so it’s crucial
to do your research and educate yourself on the potential
benefits and risks before trying this (including whether or not
the surgery you’re being recommended is truly necessary).
But from a strictly cost-savings perspective, especially if
you’re uninsured, it’s easy to see why this practice is growing.
Here is an example of the price differences for some common
procedures in the US compared to India, Thailand and Taiwan:5
US
India
Thailand
Taiwan
Hip replacement
$33,000 - $57,000
$7,200
$12,700
$8,800
Prostate surgery (TURP procedure)
$10,000 - $16,000
$3,600
$4,400
$2,750
Bypass surgery with heart valve replacement
$75,000 - $140,000
$9,500
$25,000
$30,000
Why Are US Health Care Costs so High?
Seeing the vast discrepancies in prices for medical
procedures around the globe certainly begs the question of
why US health care is so expensive. Contrary to popular
belief, it’s not typically because the US provides
better care.
The
US spends more on health care than the next 10 biggest
spenders combined: Japan, Germany, France, China, the
U.K., Italy, Canada, Brazil, Spain, and Australia. Despite that,
the US
ranks dead last in terms of quality of care among
industrialized countries, and Americans are far sicker and live
shorter lives than people in other developed nations. How is
this possible? The short answer is: We’re being fleeced.
Journalist and author Steven Brill recently discussed this very
issue in a Time magazine investigative piece, writing:6
“Simple lab work done during a few days in the
hospital can cost more than a car. A trip to the emergency
room for chest pains that turn out to be indigestion brings
a bill that can exceed the price of a semester at college.
When we debate health care policy in America, we seem to
jump right to the issue of who should pay the bills, blowing
past what should be the first question: Why exactly are the
bills so high?”
In his article, Brill gives numerous examples of shocking
markups on many hospital charges, such as $1.50 for a generic
acetaminophen tablet, when you can buy an entire bottle of 100
tablets for that amount, $18 per Accu-chek diabetes test strip
that you can purchase for about 55 cents apiece, or $283.00 for
a simple chest X-ray, for which the hospital routinely gets
$20.44 for when it treats a Medicare patient.
Even Hospital Administrators Have a Hard Time Justifying Their
Costs…
This is a Flash-based video
and may not be viewable on mobile devices.
In the video above, CNN interviews a family blindsided by
medical bills amounting to more than $474,000 after
60-year-old Bob Weinkoff spent just a few days in the ICU,
suffering from difficulty breathing. Trying to break down the
costs from an average hospital stay is daunting, however, and
may be virtually impossible for the average patient. According
to Brill, each hospital has an internal price list called a
chargemaster, which contains every single item you may be given
or come in contact with during your hospital stay. Even a toy
given to a child (which many mistake as a “gift”) can be billed
at upwards of $200. The problem is, no one quite knows how the
prices in the chargemaster are created. Brill explained:
“It would seem to be an important document. However,
I quickly found that although every hospital has a
chargemaster, officials treat it as if it were an eccentric
uncle living in the attic. Whenever I asked, they deflected
all conversation away from it…
I soon found that they have good reason to hope that
outsiders pay no attention to the chargemaster or the
process that produces it. For there seems to be no process,
no rationale, behind the core document that is the basis for
hundreds of billions of dollars in health care bills... No
hospital’s chargemaster prices are consistent with those of
any other hospital, nor do they seem to be based on anything
objective – like cost – that any hospital executive I spoke
with was able to explain. 'They were set in cement a long
time ago and just keep going up almost automatically,' says
one hospital chief financial officer with a shrug.
...That so few consumers seem to be aware of the
chargemaster demonstrates how well the health care industry
has steered the debate from why bills are so high to who
should pay them... [T]he drag on our overall economy that
comes with taxpayers, employers and consumers spending so
much more than is spent in any other country for the same
product is unsustainable. Health care is eating away at our
economy and our treasury.”
Today in the US, even nonprofit hospitals are making greater
profits than some prosperous for-profit businesses, and hospital
presidents and department heads can make upwards of $2 million
to $4 million in annual salary.
Unnecessary Procedures Are Also Common
It’s not only the inflated costs of medical care that the
average American needs to be aware of but also the high
likelihood that some of the procedures you’re being recommended
are unnecessary. According to a report by the Institute of
Medicine, an estimated 30 percent of all medical procedures,
tests and medications may in fact be unnecessary – at a cost of
at least $750 billion a year7
(plus the cost of emotional suffering and related complications
and even death – which are impossible to put numbers on).
Examples of care deemed to be of little or no benefit include
the following.8
Using feeding tubes in patients with advanced
dementia. Assisting such patients to take food
by mouth is more advantageous to the patient
EEGs on patients with recurring headaches.
The test does not improve diagnosis or outcome, only
increases cost
Routine annual PAP tests on women between the
ages of 30-65. Once every three years is enough
Leaving implantable defibrillator onwhen a patient with incurable disease has
elected to forgo resuscitation
Using cough and cold medicine in children under
the age of four suffering from respiratory illness.
These medications offer little benefit, can have serious
side effects and can lead to accidental overdose
Repeat bone scans for osteoporosis more
frequently than bi-annually. Healthy women over
67 with normal bone mass can go up to 10 years without
repeat bone scan
Use of benzodiazepines, such as Valium,
sedatives, or sleep aids in older adults with insomnia,
agitation or delirium. These drugs more than
double risk of auto accidents, falls, hip fractures, and
death
Screening healthy individuals for cancer using
CT or PET scans, as the likelihood of finding
cancer with these means is only about one percent. The
scans are likely to detect harmless growths, which lead
to additional tests, biopsies and unnecessary surgeries
Inducing labor or performing a cesarean section
for a baby who's less than full term
without medical cause. Labor induction and/or
C-section can increase the risk of learning disabilities
and respiratory problems
Routine CT scans on children with minor head
injuries. Simple observation is just as good,
and spares the child from radiation-related health risks
The Solution? Take Control of Your Health
Ultimately, the solution to avoid being ripped off by medical
care costs, or having to make a decision about whether you’re
better off traveling abroad to receive a certain procedure, is
to stay as healthy as possible by taking control of your health.
It's important to remember that the more you take responsibility
for your own health – in the form of nurturing your body to
prevent disease – the less you need to rely on the "disease
care" that passes for health care in the United States. If you
carefully follow some
basic
health principles – simple things like exercising, eating
whole foods, sleeping enough, getting sun exposure, and reducing
stress in your life – you will drastically reduce your need for
conventional medical care, which in and of itself will reduce
your chances of suffering ill side effects.
My
nutrition plan is free and can help guide you, step by step,
toward optimal health. It's now significantly improved and
contains a number of updated recommendations, such as the
addition of fermented vegetables as a source of healthful
probiotics; and using intermittent fasting and high intensity
exercise to really optimize your health.
I strongly recommend reviewing it whenever your schedule
allows. It is a very detailed and comprehensive program – it's
basically an entire book – and it is one of the most powerful
tools to truly allow you and your family to take control of your
health.