Prevalence of Lyme Disease in the US Is 10-Times Higher Than
Previously Reported
September 04, 2013
Story at-a-glance
-
According to preliminary statistics, about 300,000 new cases
of Lyme disease are diagnosed in the US each year—about 10
times higher than officially reported
-
While many still attribute Lyme transmission exclusively to
ticks, the bacteria may also be spread by other insects,
including mosquitoes, spiders, fleas, and mites
-
Lyme disease is notoriously difficult to diagnose, in part
because of its ability to mimic other disorders, such as
multiple sclerosis (MS), arthritis, chronic fatigue
syndrome, fibromyalgia, ALS, ADHD and Alzheimer's disease
-
In order to diagnose Lyme with one of the accepted
commercial tests, you must first treat it, in order for
white blood cells to mount an appropriate immune response.
Only then can a lab test detect the presence of Lyme disease
-
Controversy surrounds the issue of chronic Lyme disease, and
its treatment. While some support long-term antibiotic
treatment, this approach has potentially harmful side
effects, which is why I recommend considering alternatives
such as Dr. Klinghardt’s Lyme protocol
By Dr. Mercola
It’s now been fairly well-established that chronic
inflammation is an underlying factor in most chronic illnesses.
Diseases, such as Parkinson's, multiple sclerosis,
cardiomyopathy, gastritis, and chronic fatigue, are all turning
out to be expressions of chronic infections.
Lyme disease appears to be a major, yet oftentimes hidden,
player. This may sound shocking to you, but diagnosing Lyme is
very difficult, so the actual number of cases is high relative
to reporting.
According to preliminary statistics1,
2 just released by the Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention (CDC), approximately 300,000 new cases of Lyme
disease are diagnosed in the US each year. This is about 10
times higher than the officially reported number of cases,
indicating that the disease is being vastly underreported.
The data was presented by CDC officials at the 2013
International Conference on Lyme Borreliosis and Other
Tick-Borne Diseases in Boston in the middle of August. As
reported in the featured article by Medical News Today3:
“This agrees with studies reported in the 1990s that
showed the actual number of Lyme diseases cases in the US
was likely to be three to twelve times higher than
reported... Lyme disease is the most commonly reported
tick-borne illness in the US.”
What Is Lyme disease?
Lyme disease was named after the East Coast town of Lyme,
Connecticut, where the disease was first identified in 1975.4
The disease was first referred to as "Lyme arthritis" due to the
presentation of atypical arthritic symptoms in children that
lived in that city. By 1977, the black-legged tick (Ixodes
scapularis, also known as the deer tick) was linked to
transmission of the infection.
Then in 1982, Willy Burgdorfer, PhD, discovered the bacterium
responsible for the infection: the spirochete, named after him,
Borrelia burgdorferi,5
is a cousin to the spirochete bacterium that causes syphilis.
In fact, the two look almost identical under a microscope.
B. burgdorferi's corkscrew-shaped form allows it to
burrow into and hide in a variety of your body's tissues, which
is why it causes such wide-ranging multisystem involvement.
Borrelia burgdorferi does not just exist as a
spirochete; it has the ability to live intracellularly (inside
your cells) as an “L-form” and also encoated as a “cyst” form.
These different morphologies explain why treatment is so
difficult and recurrence of symptoms occurs after standard
antibiotic protocols.
Adding to the difficulty in treating Lyme, the organisms may
live in biofilm communities, which are basically a colony of
germs surrounded by a slimy glue-like substance that is hard to
unravel. For these reasons you will often see Lyme referred to
as “stealth.”
No doubt about it, this clever maneuvering and the pleomorphism
of the germ helps it hide and survive despite the most
aggressive antibiotics of our time. Furthermore, as reported in
the featured article:
“The Lyme disease bacterium has a quirky feature for
survival. It can exist without iron, which most other living
organisms require to make proteins and enzymes. Instead of
iron, B. burgdorferi uses manganese, thus eluding immune
system defenses that destroy pathogens by starving them of
iron.”
You May Never See the Tick That Bites
You
You can be host to the Lyme germ. The tick, which feeds off
deer, birds, animals (including your pet), then gets on you. It
numbs your skin so you won’t feel it. It prefers dark, crevices
such as your armpit or behind your ear, or your scalp. Depending
on the season, the tick may be a baby, termed a nymph.
It attaches to you (the host) and you may not see it since
nymphs are no bigger than a poppy seed. Once it attaches itself
to you it feeds on you (they are blood-suckers). At some point,
and it may be an hour or a couple of days, it will ‘spit’ its
bacterial load into you. The bacteria are released into your
blood from the infected tick via saliva. We now know there are
five subspecies of Borrelia burgdorferi, more than 100
strains in the U.S. and 300 worldwide, many of which have
developed resistance to our various antibiotics.
It’s worth noting that while many still attribute Lyme
transmission exclusively to ticks,
Dr. Deitrich Klinghardt, one of the leading authorities on
Lyme disease, warns that the bacteria can also be spread by
other insects, including mosquitoes, spiders, fleas, and mites.
This may be the reason so few Lyme sufferers recall being bitten
by a tick. The other reason of course, is that you don’t feel
the bite, and usually don’t see the tick!
In fact, fewer than half of Lyme patients recall ever getting
a tick bite. Many Lyme patients don't remember such an event
because the tick numbs your skin before biting so it is never
felt. In some studies,this number is as low as 15 percent. So,
if you don't recall seeing a tick on your body, that doesn't
rule out the possibility of Lyme disease. There’s even some
evidence pointing to Lyme disease being capable of sexual and
congenital transmission...
To add confusion to the story of Lyme disease, ticks usually
transmit more than the Borrelia organism. They could
simultaneously infect you with Bartonella, Rickettsia, Ehrlichia
and Babesia. Any or all of these organisms can travel with
Borrelia burgdorferi (the causative agent of Lyme) and each
causes a different set of symptoms. When a person has Lyme, they
often have some co-infections. Simply put, you can have one tick
bite, and wind up with five different infections. Each patient
with “Lyme disease” presents differently based upon their
co-infections, making a standard treatment plan impossible.
Treatment is based upon presentation of symptoms.
Lyme Disease: 'The Great Imitator'
Many Lyme patients who battle this disease on a daily basis
appear healthy, which is why Lyme disease has been called "the
invisible illness." They often "look good," and their routine
blood work appears normal, but their internal experience is a
far different story. Several people close to me, including my
girlfriend Erin and Suzy Cohen, R. Ph, have struggled with Lyme
disease for between 15 and 20 years. Both recently tested
positive through the GeneX blood test discussed below. This is
actually a common scenario for many Lyme patients.
The problem of misdiagnosis is typical for many Lyme patients
because conventional labs are not good at detecting the
causative agent (Borrelia burgdroferi) or it's co-infecting
pathogens. Additionally, physicians have been told for years
that Lyme does not occur in some states which is incorrect. Lyme
is in every state, and in fact worldwide.
With Lyme, the most disabling symptoms are always invisible. You
never feel completely well, there is always some issue to deal
with, and as soon as one symptom retreats, another appears. The
dial is spinning all the time. The constant and sometimes
disabling symptoms leave you physically depleted and spiritually
weakened. Complicating matters further, Lyme disease is also
notoriously difficult to diagnose, and laboratory tests are
known to be unreliable. It’s difficult to test for Lyme for a
variety of reasons, but one of the main ones is that there are
so many species of the germ, and only a handful of strains are
detectable with current lab science technology.
It Can Happen to Anyone
Because Lyme and all of its co-infections cause so many
constant symptoms, it easily mimics disorders, such as multiple
sclerosis (MS), arthritis, Parkinson’s, chronic fatigue
syndrome, fibromyalgia, ALS, ADHD and
Alzheimer's
disease. The only distinctive hallmark unique to Lyme disease is
the "bull’s-eye" rash known as Erythema Migrans,6
a red rash with an expanding red ring around it and this occurs
soon after the tick bite. After it clears up, this bull’s-eye
rash is gone.
And for the record, it’s not even always in the shape of a
bull’s eye. Perhaps now you understand why the cases reported to
the CDC have been woefully low. But as just mentioned, less than
half of all cases of Lyme can be traced to a tick bite, so this
hallmark rash is absent in many of those infected.
So how do you know if you have Lyme disease? Besides the
rash, some of the first symptoms of Lyme disease may include a
flu-like condition with fever, chills, headache, stiff neck,
achiness and fatigue. Treatment at this point is crucial because
it may help you avoid chronic Lyme. If you don’t see the tick
and remove it, it can progress to ailments like arthritis,
facial palsy, nervous system and heart problems and a hundred
other symptoms. For a more extensive list of symptoms, refer to
the Tick-Borne Disease Alliance7
(TBDA), but some of the more frequent symptoms include the
following:
- Muscle and joint pain
- Neurological problems
- Heart involvement
- Vision and hearing problems
- Migraines
To give you an example, recently the College of Charleston
President George Benson was hospitalized for Lyme disease
according to an email he addressed to campus members. Prior to
this, he had been hospitalized for severe back pain, but no one
was sure of the exact cause. His possible successor, Republican
Lt. Gov. Glenn McConnell was also ill from Lyme disease last
year according to The Associated Press. Lyme is everywhere, I
suspect that even the most recent numbers reported by the CDC
(300,000 cases) is lower than the actual real-life cases. For
more real-life examples, see the discussion below, featuring two
Lyme patients, and this recent CNN Health article8
by Erik Nivison, producer for HLN's "In Session,” who was
recently diagnosed with Lyme disease after 2 years of symptoms.
This video
may not be viewable on mobile devices.
Controversy Surrounding Lyme Disease
There’s a load of controversy around Lyme disease. In the
past, sufferers were told their ailments were “all in their
head,” and the disease was largely swept under the rug. Sadly,
this still occurs today and this is frequently missed. The
controversy for the most part today largely revolves around
whether or not antibiotics are effective against chronic Lyme
disease, and whether there even is such a thing as chronic Lyme.
According to Suzy Cohen, doctors that belong to the
Infectious Disease Society of America (IDSA) do not believe in
chronic Lyme and typically will not treat a Lyme patient beyond
four weeks. Some medical doctors and practitioners belong to the
International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society9
(ILADS) group, which does believe that Lyme can and often
persists beyond a few weeks, and are willing to treat you beyond
the four-week period.
I can tell you, chronic Lyme does exist, and no matter how
long you’ve had it, there is always hope for a full recovery. It
baffles me as to how physicians can deny infection when these
organisms are stealth and evade detection and standard treatment
protocols. As described by investigative journalist Beth Daley
in the PBS interview10
above:
“It's a very controversial disease, in large part
because there are so many questions about treatment and
lingering symptoms of people with Lyme and if people
actually have Lyme disease who are sick... [T]raditionally,
you get bit by a tick, you might see a rash or feel a fever
or you go to the doctor. They sort of diagnose you through
tests or clinically. And you would probably get three to
four weeks of oral antibiotics. And that is -- most people
agree, is usually enough to knock the disease from your
system completely. Sometimes, it goes a little bit longer if
it's more involved, but short courses of antibiotics
overall.
However, a large segment of people believe that their
symptoms linger for years sometimes, and the only way to
treat them is to use long-course antibiotics, often through
intravenously or orally, for years on end to -- so they can
live, so they can really get out of bed in the morning. And
that is a controversy. The medical establishment says,
listen, there's no proof this longer course of antibiotics
work at all. And these Lyme patients say, yes, it does...
And a lot of the debate centers on, a lot of insurance
companies won't pay for those antibiotics. As a result, lots
of people go bankrupt...”
According to Daley, there’s little discussion within the
medical community to determine whether patients with lingering
symptoms actually benefit from long-course antibiotics or not.
However, some researchers are looking into the matter.
Researchers at Yale, for example, are investigating whether the
killed-off bacteria might be leaving protein residues behind,
causing long-term symptoms. Other research being performed at
Tufts suggests that the bacteria can indeed survive, at least in
animal studies, and that this weakened bacteria might still
contribute to problems. Daley also points out that these latest
statistics really bring Lyme disease to the fore politically:
“If you just consider Massachusetts, which is --
where The Boston Globe is, we spend $10 million a year and
more on mosquito control. We spend $60,000 on tick-borne
diseases. The disparity is great. And as Lyme disease burden
grows on public health, hopefully -- I think people are
hoping that the political forces will come to bear, that
they will start seeing money to eradicate ticks in the
environment or help people learn more about them.”
I personally believe that long term antibiotic treatment is
not a wise choice for most, and that every natural alternative
should be considered prior to that strategy as there is a major
danger for impairing your beneficial bacteria and developing a
yeast or fungal co-infections, which are already common in the
disease.
The use of antifungals like fluconazole and nystatin may
certainly be appropriate and helpful when a secondary yeast
infection is present, and it often is present in cases of Lyme
disease. In an ideal world, you would boost your immune function
with a healthy diet, antioxidants such as astaxanthin and even a
compounded drug called low-dose naltrexone (LDN), known to help
your body fight harder. A gentler solution to conventional
antibiotics that can strip your body of needed probiotics and
cause a myriad of symptoms is the Nutramedix line of herbal
antimicrobials. This was developed by my friend Dr. Lee Cowden
and is often termed the “Cowden Protocol.” It is not thought to
cause resistance because this protocol cycles various herbal
antimicrobials.
Is There Such a Thing as Chronic Lyme Disease?
Slate Magazine11
ran an article earlier this summer highlighting the controversy
surrounding chronic Lyme disease, also referred to as
“post-treatment Lyme disease syndrome” (PTLDS). According to
some studies,12
PTLDS affects 0.5 to 13 percent of patients treated for Lyme:
“Doctors divide chronic Lyme disease into two
categories, broadly speaking. The first involves patients
who have a known history of infection by Borrelia
burgdorferi, the spirochete responsible for Lyme disease. A
small subgroup of patients treated for the disease
experiences aches, fatigue, and other nonspecific symptoms
more than a year after the infection clears. Whether these
symptoms have anything to do with the initial infection or
treatment is a subject of controversy among mainstream
doctors, because we don’t have enough data to make a
judgment.
Then there are patients with no proven history of
actual infection, who represent the overwhelming majority of
people claiming to suffer from chronic Lyme. This form of
chronic Lyme is controversial in the same sense that
rhinoceros horn therapy is controversial: There’s no
reliable data to support it.”
While some patients do report success on long-term antibiotic
treatments, there are clearly risks associated with such a
strategy. For one, you raise your risk of developing
antibiotic-resistant disease, and antibiotics kill off both good
and bad bacteria, making it virtually impossible to maintain
optimal gut health without rigorous reseeding of probiotics. By
disrupting your gut flora, you then expose yourself to a whole
host of other pathologies. This is an important point, and a
major part of the overall controversy. So should you be treated
with long-term antibiotics if you do not have a history of
active Lyme infection? I believe the side effects of taking
antibiotics long-term are detrimental enough to consider your
alternatives. And remember, Lyme organisms can exist in three
different forms (cyst, spirochete and L-form) so they are really
very good at hiding from antibiotics anyway.
If you are one of those people that are sensitive to alcohol,
medications, antibiotics or perfume, this is a sign that you
likely have a methylation defect in your genetics. The
methylation pathway is a detoxification pathway in your body
that clears toxins. Lyme disease sufferers often have a
methylation problem, especially those people with neurological
symptoms that are unresponsive to conventional treatments. Suzy
Cohen wrote a detailed article about methylation and explains
how to naturally circumvent this problem if you have Lyme
disease, and ease your symptoms. For that article click
here.13
Tests and Treatment Protocols for Lyme Disease
One of the reasons blood tests are so unreliable as
indicators of Lyme infection is that the spirochete has found a
way to infect your white blood cells. Lab tests rely on the
normal function of these cells to produce the antibodies they
measure. If your white cells are infected, they don't respond to
an infection appropriately. And the worse your Borrelia
infection is, the less likely it will show up on a blood test.
So, in order for Lyme tests to be useful, you have to be treated
first. Once your immune system begins to respond normally, only
then will the antibodies show up...
If your blood test comes back with positive IgM antibodies, take
this as a positive confirmation of active Lyme in your body. I
tell you this because many physicians will dismiss a positive
IgM antibody and tell you that you do not have an active
infection. They will tell you it is a false positive and not to
worry, and not to treat. Nothing could be further from the
truth. Because of a process called antigenic variation, the
proteins on the outer surface of the Lyme germ move around,
causing your body to see the germ as new and different, even if
it's been living inside your body for decades. This is what
causes the positive IgM years after the initial infection. It's
also called "epitope switching." So I want you to know that if
you have a blood test that shows positive IgM antibodies, I
would consider this a positive test, and you are best served by
getting treatment, especially if you have symptoms of Lyme.
Another reason is because a vaccine was developed years ago,
and conventional testing does not identify the most popular
surface proteins or “bands” as they are sometimes called because
those were in the original vaccine (Lymerix) now removed from
the market. So if you can’t test for the most common bands of
Lyme, how will you find the infection in people? This is yet
another reason Lyme is so underreported. If you take a standard
“Western Blot” blood test for it, your test is likely to be
negative even if you have full-blown Lyme disease.
For this reason, I recommend the specialized lab called
Igenex because they
test for more outer surface proteins (bands), and can often
detect Lyme while standard blood tests cannot. Igenex also tests
for a few strains of co-infections such as Babesia and
Erhlichia. That said, a negative on the Igenex test for these
co-infections doesn’t necessarily mean you are not infected,
there are many more strains than they can test for.
Below are the five steps Dr. Klinghardt recommends to
consider when treating Lyme Disease:
- Evaluation of all external factors. External factors
include electrosmog, EMF, microwave radiation from wireless
technologies, and molds. For more information on mold, see
Ritchie Shoemaker's
website.
- Remediation and mitigation of external factors. Once
external factors have been assessed, they're remediated and
mitigated. (Please refer to our previous article on
mold remediation.) To mitigate microwave radiation, Dr.
Klinghardt recommends shielding the outside of your home
with a graphite paint called Y Shield. Inside, he uses a
special silver-coated cloth for your curtains. Patients are
instructed to remove all cordless telephones and turn off
all the fuses at night, until they have recovered from Lyme
disease.
- Addressing emotional issues. Emotional components of the
disease are addressed using Energy Psychology tools,
including psychokinesiology (PK), which is similar to the
Emotional Freedom
Technique (EFT), but more refined and advanced.
- Addressing parasitic, bacterial and viral infections.
Dr. Klinghardt addresses the parasites first, followed by
the bacteria and the viruses. The "Klinghardt antimicrobial
cocktail," which includes wormwood (artemisinin),
phospholipids, vitamin C, and various herbs, is an integral
part of this treatment. He addresses viral infections with
Viressence (by BioPure), which is a tincture of Native
American herbs.
- Addressing other lifestyle factors.
Nutritional considerations and supplements are
addressed.
Also, the following table lists a variety of different
treatment strategies that have been found to be useful in Lyme
disease by those embracing natural methods.
|
Probiotics to improve immunity and restore microflora
during and after antibiotics |
Curcumin is helpful at reducing neurological toxins and
brain swelling |
|
Astaxanthin to neutralize toxins, improve vision &
relieve joint pain, common in Lyme |
Whey protein concentrate may help with nutrition, often
poor in Lyme patients who don’t feel well enough to eat
properly |
|
Grapefruit seed extract may treat the cyst form of
Borrelia |
Krill oil to reduce inflammation |
|
Cilantro as a natural chelator for heavy metals |
Serrapeptase helps to break biofilms |
|
Resveratrol may treat Bartonella, a co-infection and
also helps detoxification |
GABA and melatonin to help with insomnia |
|
Artemisinin and Andrographis, two herbs that may treat
Babesia, a common co-infection |
CoQ10 to support cardiac health and reduce muscle pain
and brain fog |
|
Quercetin reduces histamine (often high in Lyme) |
Transfer factors can help boost immune function |
Tips for Preventing Lyme Disease
Clearly, preventing infection is your best strategy. To avoid
tick and other
insect bites, make sure to tuck your pants into socks and
wear closed shoes and a hat—especially if venturing out into
wooded areas. The CDC also recommends cutting down your risk of
Lyme and other tickborne diseases by following these steps14:
|
Check for ticks daily, on yourself, your child and pets
|
Bathe or shower soon after being outdoors (preferably
within two hours) to wash off and more easily find any
lingering ticks or tick bites |
If you’ve been in a tick-infested area, do a careful
full body check. Use a mirror to view all parts of your
body |
|
Check for ticks in your child’s hair, under the arms, in
and around the ears, the belly button, between the legs,
around the waist, and behind the knees |
Inspect clothing for ticks. Tumble clothes on high heat
for an hour to kill ticks you may have missed |
See a doctor if you develop a telltale “bull’s-eye” rash |
Additional Resources
In Dr. Klinghardt's experience, the International Lyme and
Associated Disease Society15
(ILADS) is by far the best and most responsible group. The
following are some other resources you might find helpful:
- "Under Our Skin" website16
- Tick-Borne Disease Alliance17
(TBDA)
- Lymedisease.org18
(formerly CALDA)
Another leading Lyme disease expert Richard Horowitz, MD and
author of the new book,
Why Can’t I Get Better? Solving the Mystery of Lyme and
Chronic Disease, has stated:
“This condition is better termed Lyme MSIDS, short
for Multiple Systemic Infectious Disease Syndrome. MSIDS is
like Pandora’s Box because it includes many infections,
co-infections and secondary infections. Treatment should be
tailored to each patient individually.”
© Copyright 1997-2013 Dr. Joseph Mercola. All Rights Reserved.
http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2013/09/04/lyme-disease.aspx
|