Raw Milk versus Pasteurized—Which Is Safer?
July 22, 2014
Story at-a-glance
-
In sharp contrast to the US, where several states have
banned raw milk sales, France, Croatia, Switzerland,
Austria, the Netherlands, and Italy sell raw milk in
vending machines
-
The vast majority of foodborne illnesses in the US are
linked to factory farmed and highly processed foods, not
raw foods
-
Last year, Chobani Greek yoghurt was recalled following
reports of gastrointestinal illness. The yogurt, which
is pasteurized and not raw, was found to be contaminated
with a fungus called Murcor circinelloides
-
Disease-causing bacteria are the result of industrial
farming practices that lead to diseased animals, which
may then in turn produce contaminated milk
-
California has among the highest standards for raw milk
for human consumption, in which farmers must meet or
exceed pasteurized milk standards, without pasteurizing
By Dr. Mercola
The United States lags far behind many other nations when it
comes to food safety and nutritional recommendations, and this
is perhaps particularly true when it comes to raw milk.
The fact is, large dairy farmers operating under the factory
farm model simply cannot produce raw milk safe for human
consumption.
They're too large, and therefore end up being hotbeds for
pathogenic contamination. They also cannot provide enough open
pasture for tens of thousands of cows to continually graze on.
Cleanliness and pasture are critical parameters for
producing healthy milk fit for raw consumption. So really, the
war on raw milk boils down to control—controlling the
competition, which is selling a superior product. It's NOT an
issue of safety at all.
In fact, several studies have demonstrated the superior
safety of raw milk compared to pasteurized, yet the vilification
of raw milk continues unabated—science and statistics be
damned...
Europeans Can Buy Raw Milk from Vending Machines
In sharp contrast to the US, some European nations sell raw
milk in vending machines! And contrary to popular
(American) belief, the bodies are NOT piling up as a result. As
reported by Modern Farmer:1
"Europe's embrace of raw milk vending machines isn't
new. Such daring dispensers of unpasteurized dairy can be
found in France, Croatia, Switzerland, Austria, the
Netherlands and, as one map2
shows, all over the place in Italy."
The safety measures are remarkably simple. If the temperature
of the milk rises above the regulated level, the machine will
stop dispensing milk, and the farmer is notified via text
message. The milk spout is sterilized by a UV light between each
purchase.
In the US, several states have outright banned the sale of
raw milk for fear of contaminated milk despite the fact that,
statistically, such fears are completely and udderly unfounded
(pun intended).
Research by Dr. Ted Beals, MD,3
featured in the summer 2011 issue of Wise Traditions,
the quarterly journal of the Weston A. Price Foundation, shows
that you are actually about 35,000 times more likely to get sick
from other foods than you are from raw milk!
Pasteurized Dairy and Processed Foods Top the List of 'Most
Dangerous'
The vast majority of foodborne illnesses in the US are linked
to factory farmed and highly processed foods, not raw foods. For
example, late last year, Chobani Greek yogurt was recalled
following reports of gastrointestinal illness.4
The yogurt, which is pasteurized and not raw, was found to be
contaminated with a fungus called Murcor circinelloides.
In 2011, Cargill recalled a whopping 36 million pounds of
ground turkey.5
An antibiotic-resistant strain of Salmonella in the
meat ended up causing 107 illnesses and one death.
An investigation revealed that this strain of Salmonella
had been found four times over the course of one year,
yet the US Department of Agriculture (USDA), took no action
against the producer. And, from the time the first illness was
reported and the recall took effect, five months passed,
allowing over a hundred more people to become ill from the
contaminated meat.
A major part of the problem is that, despite being in charge
of food safety oversight of meat and poultry, the USDA does not
have the authority to take action against a meat or poultry
producer—even if the permissible limits of pathogenic
contamination are repeatedly exceeded.
Clearly, this does not bode well for food safety. As
explained in a previous Food Safety News article discussing this
case:6
"For example, take ground turkey. When USDA tests for
Salmonella, they take individual 1-pound samples on 52
consecutive days of production. Sometimes it takes a year to
complete a set — and the establishment gets a heads up that
a sample is going to be taken!
In addition, if 26 or fewer are positive, the sample
set passes. If more than 26 are positive, the sample set
fails.
Basically, these are like open book exams — not pop
quizzes — where a 50 percent is still passing! And even when
a sample set fails, USDA does another set of testing. And
they keep doing testing until a set passes."
What this means is that if 50 percent of the samples are
contaminated with disease-causing bacteria, it's deemed "safe."
But if it hits 51 percent, it's tagged as "unsafe." And testing
simply continues until illness is reported. What sense does this
make?
Yet anytime the lack of food safety is discussed, the focus
is suddenly turned to raw milk! It's almost as
though US agencies are using raw milk as a scapegoat to keep you
from looking at the real problem, which is that factory
farms produce inherently unsafe foods. It's like a
propaganda machine sleight of hand maneuver...
CDC Stance on Raw Milk—As Biased as It Gets
Mark McAfee, CEO of Organic Pastures Dairy and an
internationally recognized expert in raw milk production and
safety, has on numerous occasions tried to set the record
straight with US authorities, to no avail. In a 2012 letter to
the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), he writes:7
"As a grade A producer of retailed-approved raw milk
in California, I find your raw milk page filled with highly
erroneous and very misleading information... In California,
we have legal retail-approved raw milk in 400 stores
consumed by 75,000 consumers each week. This retail legal
raw milk is tested and state inspected and far exceeds
pasteurized milk product standards without any heat or
processing.
It is clean raw milk from a single source dairy.
There have been no deaths from raw milk in California in 37
years. Two years ago, I submitted a FOIA request to the CDC
to request data on the two deaths that the CDC database
claims were from raw milk. The data I received back from the
CDC showed that in fact there had been no death from raw
milk at all.
The two deaths had been from illegal Mexican bath tub
cheese and not raw milk from any place in America. Why does
the CDC persist in publishing this erroneous information?
...The last people to die from milk died from pasteurized
milk at Whittier farms in 2007, not from raw milk."
While both the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the
CDC warn that raw milk can carry disease-causing bacteria, they
completely overlook the fact that these bacteria are the result
of industrial farming practices that lead to diseased
animals, which may then in turn produce contaminated milk.
They make no distinction whatsoever between disease-riddled
factory farmed milk and the milk from clean, healthy, grass-fed
cows. This is indeed a key issue, as raw milk from a confined
animal feeding operation (CAFO) IS dangerous and must
be pasteurized in order to be fit to drink, whereas raw milk
from cows raised on pasture IS NOT dangerous and DOES NOT need
pasteurization. The source of the milk makes all the difference
when it comes to raw milk.
What the CDC Doesn't Tell You About Raw Milk Is Worth Knowing...
The CDC also fails to inform visitors in its website that
legal raw milk producers oftentimes adhere to stricter
safety standards than CAFOs do. California, specifically, has
its own special set of standards for raw milk for human
consumption, in which farmers must meet or exceed pasteurized
milk standards, without pasteurizing.
Instead of giving you the facts, the CDC lists raw milk as
one of the riskiest foods in America, without any real proof to
back up such a proclamation. The American Academy of Pediatrics
(AAP) has even called for a complete ban on raw milk because it
is so "dangerous." But on what do they base their assumptions?
On the CDC's unproven opinion? If safety was truly the issue,
then pasteurized dairy would be banned, as that's
what's causing the most disease.
So you've got to ask yourself, is this really about our
personal safety or the safety of the milk industry? Eating
directly from the farm is prohibited by industry so they can
control our food supply. They make it very difficult for farmers
to sell directly to us, whether dairy products or meat products.
They claim this is done for our safety, but it's really just a
plot to control our food system.
"The FDA does not mention raw milk on their top 10
most risky foods in America list," McAfee notes.
"Pasteurized ice cream and pasteurized cheeses make the top
10 risky foods list... According to the Cornell study
performed on CDC data, there were 1,100 illnesses caused by
raw milk between 1973 and 2009. There were 422,000 illnesses
caused by pasteurized milk. No deaths from raw milk and at
least 50 deaths from pasteurized milk or pasteurized
cheese—the CDC left out the 29 or more people that died from
the pasteurized Jalisco cheese listeria incident in 1985."
Raw Milk Has Many Health Benefits
The CDC, as McAfee notes, is absolutely riddled with bias.
While most of it is obvious, some of the bias is hidden by the
way the CDC counts its statistics. For example, it counts
outbreaks rather than the number of people affected by the
outbreak. In one outbreak caused by pasteurized milk,
200,000 people fell ill! Yet it's only counted as one
incident. Its website also makes no mention whatsoever to
studies showing how raw organic milk differs, nutritionally,
from CAFO milk, and how it improves health. For example, raw
milk is:
|
Loaded with healthy bacteria that are good for your
gastrointestinal tract |
High in omega-3 and low omega-6, which is the beneficial
ratio between these two essential fats |
|
Full of more than 60 digestive enzymes, growth factors,
and immunoglobulins (antibodies). These enzymes are
destroyed during pasteurization, making pasteurized milk
much harder to digest |
Loaded with vitamins (A, B, C, D, E, and K) in highly
bioavailable forms, and a very balanced blend of
minerals (calcium, magnesium, phosphorus, and iron)
whose absorption is enhanced by live Lactobacilli |
|
Rich in conjugated linoleic acid (CLA), which fights
cancer and boosts metabolism |
Rich in healthy unoxidized cholesterol |
|
Rich in beneficial raw fats, amino acids, and proteins
in a highly bioavailable form, all 100 percent
digestible |
It also contains phosphatase, an enzyme that aids and
assists in the absorption of calcium in your bones, and
lipase enzyme, which helps to hydrolyze and absorb fats |
Pasteurizing milk, on the other hand, destroys enzymes,
diminishes vitamins, denatures fragile milk proteins, destroys
vitamin B12 and vitamin B6, kills beneficial bacteria, and
actually promotes pathogens.
Max Kane's Self-Healing Is a Testament to the Power of Raw Dairy
In the video above, I interview Max Kane, a local raw dairy
farmer from whom our office purchases a variety of raw dairy
products from. Max was diagnosed with Crohn's disease at the age
of 10. Through years of study, he eventually healed himself
through nutrition and lifestyle changes. He now consumes only
100 percent raw, 100 percent organic, and 100 percent
pasture-raised dairy products. Raw dairy makes up about 50
percent of his diet.
"The cream is perhaps the most important part of the
milk because the cream is where all the energy is that's
needed to digest the milk protein casein," he explains.
"That's why it's important to consume full-fat dairy
products instead of non-fat or skim dairy products. The
cream is also responsible for regulating the sugar
absorption into your blood. It decreases the likelihood of
insulin spikes. The cream naturally floats to the top of the
milk, and it can be skimmed right off the top.
Traditionally, people would use the cream line as a visual
aid to help them assess the quality of the milk...
Homogenization [is] an industry process that
fractionates the cream molecule, the fat molecule, into
small little pieces. This was done for the purpose of making
the cream line non-detectable to the human eye... That's how
they standardized the milk, by taking away the viewable
quality assessment from the consumer, and ultimately left
the consumer with no real visual way to assess the quality
and the value of the milk."
The quality of grass-fed milk, butter, and yogurt can easily
be ascertained by its color. The carotenoids in the plants cows
eat on pasture gives grass-fed products a more yellow-orange
cast. When cows are raised on dried grass or hay, opposed to
fresh-growing grass, you end up with a whiter product, which is
an indication of reduced carotenoid and antioxidant content. Raw
milk yogurt is also very thick and creamy, compared to
pasteurized commercial varieties. The same goes for pastured
eggs, which can be ascertained by their deep orange yolk. CAFO
chickens, which never go outdoors, and are fed grains rather
than bugs and insects, produce eggs with pale yellow yolks.
ABOUT Max Kane - Max Kane was diagnosed with
Crohn's disease at the age of 10, and through years of study,
healed himself through nutrition and lifestyle changes. 100% of
his dairy products and over 50% of his other foods are purchased
directly from farms. When it comes to dairy, he only consumes
100% raw, 100% organic, 100% grass-fed. Dairy makes up about 50%
of his diet. After realizing the healing power of fresh farm
foods, Kane teamed up with Amagisoft to create
FarmMatch.com.
ABOUT FarmMatch
-- It's free to create an account, but no account is
required to use the system.
FarmMatch is built over the Google mapping system and makes
local food searchable worldwide, making it easy to find a local
farmer. Not only are specific farm products searchable, but
products are searchable by quality standards as well… 100%
grass-fed, non-GMO, etc. You can connect with farmers and buy
online as well. The order management system is consumer funded.
Buyers pay a $2.95 fee when placing an order or can opt into a
$3.95/month plan that allows unlimited ordering with no $2.95
fees. Through these small affordable consumer fees, FarmMatch
delivers a state-of-the-art software suit to every small scale
farmer at no charge to the farmer. The FarmMatch business model
not only helps individual small farmers, but it also lifts the
entire local food movement as a whole.
Join the Fight for Food Freedom
The fight over raw milk stands as a symbol of the much larger
fight for food freedom. Who gets to decide what you eat? You? Or
the FDA? If the FDA and other government agencies are allowed to
impose their view of "safe food" on consumers, raw milk won't be
the only thing lost—all food will be pasteurized, irradiated,
and genetically engineered. The effort to reclaim our right to
buy and consume raw milk is leading the way for everyone who
wants to be able to obtain the food of their choice from the
source of their choice. So please, get involved! I urge you to
get involved with the following action plan to protect your
right to choose your own foods:
- Get informed: Visit
www.farmtoconsumer.org or
click here to sign up for action alerts. To review the
raw milk laws in your state, see the Farm-to-Consumer.org's
Raw
Milk Nation page.
- Join the fight for your rights: The
Farm-to-Consumer Legal Defense Fund (FTCLDF) is the only
organization of its kind. This 501(c)(4) nonprofit
organization provides a legal defense for farmers who are
being pursued by the government for distributing foods
directly to consumers. Your
donations, although not tax deductible, will be used to
support the litigation, legislative, and lobbying efforts of
the FTCLDF.
- Support your local farmers: Getting
your raw milk from a local organic farm or co-op is one of
the best ways to ensure you're getting high-quality milk.
You can locate a raw milk source near you at the Campaign
for Real
Milk Website. California residents can find raw milk
retailers by using the store locator available at
www.OrganicPastures.com.
Copyright 1997- 2014 Dr. Joseph Mercola. All Rights Reserved.
http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2014/07/22/raw-vs-pasteurized-milk.aspx
|