New Dietary Guidelines Reverse
Flawed Recommendations on Cholesterol
February 25, 2015
Story at-a-glance
Limitations for cholesterol will likely be removed
from the 2015 edition of Dietary Guidelines for
Americans; overconsumption of dietary cholesterol is
now cited as being of no concern
A recent review of studies investigating the link
between dietary fat and causes of death concluded
that recommendations to reduce the amount of fat we
eat every day should never have been made
When fat was removed from processed foods, sugar was
added in. This has led to a massive increase in
obesity, diabetes, and non-alcoholic fatty liver
disease, even among children
By Dr. Mercola
For the past half century, cholesterol has been touted as a grave
health hazard, and dietary fat and cholesterol have been portrayed
as being among the “deadliest” foods you could possibly eat.
This may finally change, as limitations for cholesterol will
likely be removed from the 2015 edition of Dietary Guidelines for
Americans. It’s about time really, as 60 years’ worth of research
has utterly failed to demonstrate a correlation between high
cholesterol and heart disease.
Not only does undamaged natural cholesterol not cause
heart disease, it is actually one of the most important molecules in
your body; indispensable for the building of cells and for producing
stress and sex hormones, as well as vitamin D.
Cholesterol is also important for brain health, and helps with
the formation of your memories. Low levels of HDL cholesterol have
been linked to memory loss and
Alzheimer's disease, and may also increase your risk of
depression, stroke,
violent behavior, and even suicide.
New American Dietary Guidelines May Remove Limits on Cholesterol
A draft1
of the 2015 edition of Dietary Guidelines for Americans,2
created by the Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee, now states
that “cholesterol is not considered a nutrient of concern for
overconsumption.”
And, according to a recent report in the Washington Post,3
an insider claims the new stance on cholesterol will remain in the
final report. As noted by medical journalist Larry Husten:4
“The proposed change reflects a major shift in the
scientific view of cholesterol that has taken place in recent
years.
Although serum cholesterol is still considered an
important risk factor, cholesterol consumed in food is now
thought to play a relatively insignificant role in determining
blood levels of cholesterol.”
However, if you process saturated fat or cholesterol and heat it
by frying, then you create very dangerous products that will
clearly increase your risk of cardiovascular disease. So this new
information does not give you free license to eat any type of
cholesterol. Remember, trans fats are worse than sugar for your
health.
Guidelines on Fat and Cholesterol Should Never Have Been Made
Steve Nissen, chairman of cardiovascular medicine at the
Cleveland Clinic, told USA Today:5
“It’s the right decision. We got the dietary guidelines wrong.
They’ve been wrong for decades.” This message was echoed in Time
Magazine, which recently reported that:
“[I]n the latest review6
of studies that investigated the link between dietary fat and
causes of death, researchers say the guidelines got it all
wrong. In fact, recommendations to reduce the amount of fat we
eat every day should never have been made.”
Low-fat diets saw a real upswing in 1977, but according to
research published in the Open Heart journal,7
led by Zoe Harcombe, PhD, there was no scientific basis for the
recommendations to cut fat from our diet in the first place.
What’s worse, the processed food industry replaced fat with large
amounts of sugar, While Dr. Harcombe shies away from making any
recommendation about how much dietary fat might be ideal, she
suggests that the take-home message here is to simply “eat real
food.”
I have to say, it’s refreshing to finally see that message being
repeated in the mainstream media. As reported by Time Magazine:8
“The less adulterated and processed your diet is, the
more nutrients and healthy fats, proteins and carbohydrates your
body will get, and the less you’ll have to worry about meeting
specific guidelines or advice that may or may not be based on a
solid body of evidence.”
Processed Fructose Affects Your Body Like Alcohol
The low-fat craze led to an avalanche of new processed food
products, promising to benefit both your waistline and your heart.
Alas, nothing could have been further from the truth.
When fat was removed, sugar was added in, and this has led to a
massive increase in obesity, diabetes, heart disease, and
non-alcoholic fatty liver disease. As it turns out, your body
metabolizes fructose in the same way it metabolizes ethanol,
creating the same toxic effects.
Unlike glucose, which can be used by virtually every cell in your
body, fructose can only be metabolized by your liver,
because your liver is the only organ that has the transporter for
it.
Since nearly all fructose gets shuttled to your liver, and, if
you eat a typical Western-style diet, you consume high amounts of
it, fructose ends up taxing and damaging your liver in the same way
alcohol and other toxins do.
In fact, when you compare the health outcomes of fructose versus
alcohol consumption, you see the diseases they cause are virtually
identical:
Chronic Ethanol Consumption
Chronic Fructose Consumption
Hypertension
Hypertension
Cardiomyopathy
Myocardial
infarction
Dyslipidemia
Dyslipidemia
Pancreatitis
Pancreatitis
Obesity
Obesity
Hepatic
dysfunction (ASH)
Hepatic
dysfunction (NASH)
Fetal alcohol
syndrome
Fetal insulin
resistance
Addiction
Habituation,
if not addiction
Non-Alcoholic Liver Disease Has Become a Serious Public Health
Concern
Dr. Robert Lustig, Professor of Pediatrics in the Division of
Endocrinology at the University of California, has been a pioneer in
decoding
sugar metabolism and sounding the alarm on processed fructose in
particular.
In one of his papers,9
published in the Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and
Dietetics in 2010, Dr. Lustig describes three similarities
between fructose and its fermentation byproduct, ethanol (alcohol):
Your liver's metabolism of fructose is similar to alcohol as
they both serve as substrates for converting dietary
carbohydrate into fat, which promotes insulin resistance,
dyslipidemia (abnormal fat levels in the bloodstream), and fatty
liver
Fructose undergoes the Maillard reaction with proteins,
leading to the formation of superoxide free radicals that can
result in liver inflammation similar to acetaldehyde, an
intermediary metabolite of ethanol
By "stimulating the 'hedonic pathway' of the brain both
directly and indirectly," Dr. Lustig noted, "fructose creates
habituation, and possibly dependence; also paralleling ethanol"
As recently reported in Scientific American,10
non-alcoholic fatty liver disease11
(NAFLD) now affects an estimated 25 percent of Americans, including
an estimated 20 percent of children, who have never had a drop of
alcohol. Cases of NAFLD have even been reported in children as young
as three years old. This may sound like an impossibility. But did
you know that most infant formulas contain the sugar equivalent of a
can of Coca-Cola?
Ditto for many
baby foods, which can contain as much sugar and harmful trans
fats as chocolate cookies or cheeseburgers. Babies are methodically
“poisoned” with exorbitant amounts of refined sugar and processed
fructose from day one, so it’s really no wonder that so many of our
youngsters struggle with weight issues and associated diseases. As
explained in Scientific American:12
“NAFLD describes the accumulation of fat in hepatocytes,
or liver cells, in excessive amounts. These fats are typically
triglycerides, which the body naturally stores and creates from
calories that it doesn’t need right away. Normally these fats
are burned off for energy, but if the body is overwhelmed with
calories and a lack of exercise, then the triglycerides are
simply never released. They instead accumulate in the liver and
cause NAFLD, which can lead to inflammation, scarring, liver
dysfunction and even liver cancer.”
Wrong Dietary Guidelines Has Led to Flawed Medical Interventions,
Too
Since the cholesterol hypothesis is false, this also means that
the recommended therapies—low-fat, low-cholesterol diet, and
cholesterol lowering medications—are doing more harm than good.
Statin treatment, for example, is largely harmful, costly, and has
transformed millions of people into patients whose health is being
adversely impacted by the drug. As noted in the featured video, we
now know a whole lot more about HDL and LDL, commonly referred to as
“good” and “bad” cholesterol respectively, although that is also a
bit of a fallacy.
Depending on the size of the particles, LDL may be either harmful
or harmless, so LDL is not necessarily “bad” across the
board. The
issue of particle sizes is discussed in greater detail in my
2013 interview with Chris Kresser, L.Ac. If you’ve had your
cholesterol levels checked, your doctor most likely tested your
total cholesterol, LDL cholesterol, HDL cholesterol, and
triglycerides. But we now know those are not accurate predictors for
cardiovascular disease risk.
A far more accurate predictor is your LDL particle number,
the test for which is called an NMR Lipoprofile. It’s easy to get
and all major labs offer it, including LabCorp and Quest. Most
insurance policies cover the test as well. Best of all, even if your
doctor were to refuse to order it, you can order it yourself via
third-party intermediaries like Direct Labs, or you can order the
test online, and get blood drawn locally. Also:
Check your HDL to total cholesterol ratio.
HDL percentage is a potent heart disease risk factor. Just
divide your HDL level by your cholesterol. This ratio should
ideally be above 24 percent.
Boost your HDL cholesterol and lower your
triglyceride levels. High triglycerides are a very
potent risk factor for heart disease. In combination, high
triglycerides and low HDL levels are an even bigger risk; this
ratio is far more important to your heart health than the
standard good vs. bad cholesterol ratio. In fact, one study
found that people with the highest ratio of triglycerides to HDL
had 16 times the
risk of heart attack as those with the lowest ratio of
triglycerides to HDL.
You calculate your triglyceride/HDL cholesterol ratio by
dividing your triglyceride level by your HDL level. This ratio
should ideally be below 2. So while you strive to keep your HDL
cholesterol levels up, you'll want to decrease your
triglycerides. You’ll find strategies for increasing your HDL
level below. Triglycerides are easily decreased by exercising
and avoiding grains and sugars in your diet.
Statins Are Based on a Flawed Premise
Part of the reason why cholesterol-lowering drugs like
statins are ineffective
for heart disease prevention (besides the fact that the drug
causes heart disease as a side effect) is that drugs cannot
address the real cause of heart disease, which is insulin and
leptin resistance, which in turn increase your LDL particle
number via a number of different mechanisms. While some genetic
predisposition can play a role, insulin and leptin resistance is
primarily caused by a combination of factors that are epidemic in
our modern lifestyle:
A diet high in processed and refined carbohydrates,
sugars/fructose, refined flours, and industrial seed oils
Insufficient everyday physical activity.
Chronic sitting is also an independent risk factor that
causes biochemical changes that predispose you to insulin and
leptin resistance, even if you’re very fit and exercise
regularly
Chronic sleep deprivation. Studies have shown that even one
night of disturbed sleep can decrease your insulin sensitivity
the next day and cause cravings and overeating
Environmental toxins. Exposure to BPA, for example, can
disrupt weight regulation
Poor gut health. Studies indicate that imbalances in your
gut flora (the bacteria that live in our gut) can predispose you
to obesity and insulin and
leptin resistance, and processed foods high in sugar
effectively feed harmful bacteria, allowing them to take over
For Heart Health, Focus on Boosting Your HDL
A healthy diet is foundational for optimal health, and step
number one is to ignore the advice to eat a low-fat, low-cholesterol
diet. Other strategies that will help reduce your risk of heart
disease include the following:13
Replace processed foods (which are loaded with refined
sugar and carbs, processed fructose, and trans fat—all of
which promote heart disease) with whole, unprocessed or
minimally processed foods, ideally organic and/or locally
grown.
Avoid meats and other animal products such as dairy and
eggs sourced from animals raised in confined animal feeding
operations (CAFOs). Instead, opt for grass-fed, pastured
varieties, raised according to organic standards.
Eliminate no-fat and low-fat foods, and increase
consumption of healthy fats. Half of the population suffers
with insulin resistance and would benefit from consuming
50-85 percent of their daily calories from healthy saturated
fats, such as avocados, butter made from raw grass-fed
organic milk, raw dairy, organic pastured egg yolks,
coconuts and coconut oil, unheated organic nut oils, raw
nuts, and grass-fed meats. No- or low-fat foods are usually
processed foods that are high in sugar, which raises your
small, dense LDL particles.
Balancing your omega-3 to omega-6 ratio is also key for
heart health, as these fatty acids help build the cells in
your arteries that make the prostacyclin that keeps your
blood flowing smoothly.
Omega-3
deficiency can cause or contribute to very serious health
problems, both mental and physical, and may be a significant
underlying factor of up to 96,000 premature deaths each
year. For more information about omega-3s and the best
sources of this fat, please
review this previous article.
You also need the appropriate ratios of calcium,
magnesium,
sodium, and potassium, and all of these are generally
abundant in a whole food diet. To get more fresh vegetables
into your diet, consider
juicing.
Optimize your vitamin D level. Some researchers, like
Dr. Stephanie Seneff, believe optimizing your vitamin D
level through regular sun exposure, opposed to taking an
oral supplement, may be key to optimizing your
heart health. If you do opt for a supplement, you also
increase your need for vitamin K2. Meanwhile, Dr. Robert
Heaney recently highlighted research showing that
carnivorous animals actually get some of the
vitamin D they need from the meat they eat. For the
longest time, meat was not considered a good source of
vitamin D, primarily because it was so difficult to measure
that we didn’t think it contained useful amounts. He
recommends getting approximately 5,000 to 6,000 IUs of
vitamin D per day from all sources – sun,
supplements, and food – in order to reach and maintain a
healthy blood level of 40-60 ng/ml.
Optimize your gut health. Regularly eating fermented
foods, such as fermented vegetables, will help reseed your
gut with beneficial bacteria that may play an important role
in preventing heart disease and countless other health
problems.
Quit smoking and reduce your alcohol consumption.
Exercise regularly.
Exercise is actually one of the safest, most effective
ways to prevent and treat heart disease. In 2013,
researchers at Harvard and Stanford reviewed 305 randomized
controlled trials, concluding there were "no statistically
detectable differences" between physical activity and
medications for heart disease.
High-intensity interval training, which requires but a
fraction of the time compared to conventional cardio, has
been shown to be especially effective.
Pay attention to your oral health. There's convincing
evidence linking the state of your teeth and gums to a
variety of health issues, including heart disease. In one
2010 study,14
those with the worst oral hygiene increased their risk of
developing heart disease by 70 percent, compared to those
who brush their teeth twice a day.
Avoid statins, as the side effects of these drugs are
numerous, while the benefits are debatable. In my view, the
only group of people who may benefit from a
cholesterol-lowering medication are those with genetic
familial hypercholesterolemia. This is a condition
characterized by abnormally high cholesterol, which tends to
be resistant to lowering with lifestyle strategies like diet
and exercise.
Copyright 1997- 2015 Dr. Joseph Mercola. All Rights Reserved.