* Saudi Arabia may shoulder cut burden
* Exemptions make for difficult math
* Non-OPEC participation in doubt
A month into their endeavor to finalize a preliminary freeze pact
agreed in Algiers, OPEC countries will gather in Vienna on Friday
for a two-day technical meeting to try and bridge the substantial
gaps in their positions.
Though OPEC's 14 members emerged from Algiers with a tentative plan
to freeze their total oil output between 32.5 million to 33 million
b/d -- its first cut since 2008 -- almost immediately divisions
emerged within the group about how to accomplish that.
Iraq is insisting on a higher quota or an exemption from the freeze
as it battles the Islamic State militant group.
OPEC kingpin Saudi Arabia, meanwhile, has insisted that all
members must act collectively in any output deal, though it has said
it will allow "special consideration" -- including potentially
exemptions -- for Iran, Libya and Nigeria, as they recover from
presumably temporary setbacks.
The cooperation of key non-OPEC producers, likely vital to a
meaningful deal that the market views as credible, is an open
question, as well.
A flurry of bilateral and multilateral meetings over the last few
weeks has not resolved any of these issues, so the technical meeting
that begins Friday will be closely watched for any signs of
consensus -- or discord.
The meeting will not involve country ministers but experts from each
country, as a precursor to higher level meetings scheduled for next
month, leading up to a self-imposed November 30 deadline to finalize
the freeze.
"The stakes are high this time," said Vandana Hari, a
Singapore-based analyst with Vanda Insights. "No one has any
illusions about the rocky road to cobbling together a production cut
agreement and reimposing production quotas on member countries."
OPEC would have to cut between 390,000 to 890,000 b/d from September
levels to meet the freeze range, according to the organization's own
estimate.
More mundane details -- a start date for enforcement, an end date,
and monitoring mechanisms -- also need to be agreed.
Mindful of April's Doha summit collapse, when a deal to freeze
production at January levels fell apart at the 11th hour, causing
OPEC much embarrassment, most market watchers expect some kind of
agreement to emerge.
Whether it will provide any significant market impact and accelerate
the drawdown of stocks, as OPEC has said is the aim, remains to be
seen.
"OPEC will have to come up with a plan, as it would otherwise be
seen as a huge failure," said Ole Hansen, Copenhagen-based head of
commodity strategy for Saxo Bank. "To fail when action is promised
could trigger a big and unwanted selloff in the market."
EXEMPTIONS IN FOCUS
Many forecasters, including the International Energy Agency and the
US Energy Information Administration, have said the OPEC freeze
could accelerate the market's rebalancing, which otherwise would
occur in the back half of 2017, though the devil will be in the
details.
How OPEC plans to accommodate the exemptions for Iran, Libya and
Nigeria is among the key unknowns.
Libya has said its production now exceeds 580,000 b/d, with more to
come, now that its previously blockaded ports are returning to full
action.
Nigeria, meanwhile, has said its production is up to 1.9 million
b/d, with a capacity of 2.4 million b/d, as it attempts to broker a
lasting truce with militants that have attacked oil pipelines and
other facilities.
Iran has seen its production reach 3.67 million b/d, according to
OPEC's most recent monthly oil market report. The country has
ambitions to reach the approximately 4 million b/d output level it
had before Western sanctions imposed over its nuclear program
hobbled its oil sector.
Those exemptions likely will cause more of the burden of cutting to
fall on Saudi Arabia, which has repeatedly declined to lower its
output without reciprocity from other producers.
Several other non-exempt OPEC countries are not in any financial
condition to contribute to a production cut, such as Algeria and
Venezuela.
Working in OPEC's favor is that the peak summer air conditioning
season has passed, reducing Saudi Arabia's direct crude burn.
Harry Tchilinguirian, London-based global head of commodity strategy
for BNP Paribas, said he does not expect Saudi Arabia to cut much
further than it has to, given the market share strategy that it has
embraced.
Cuts too far could cause prices to rebound, risking a loss of market
share to US shale producers and other rivals within and outside of
OPEC.
"We doubt that Saudi Arabia will want to assume the entire burden of
output adjustment alone and hand back all the gains in market share
that it achieved over past two years," Tchilinguirian said.
FURTHER HURDLES
Analysts also doubt that OPEC will be willing to accommodate Iraq's
request for a higher quota or exemption.
Iraq officials have insisted the country will not reduce its output
from current levels of around 4.7 million b/d -- and could even
raise production -- no matter how the freeze is implemented.
But agreeing to an exemption for Iraq could prompt other countries
to also seek concessions, rendering the freeze moot.
"Unlike Iran, Libya and Nigeria, Iraq's excuse is flimsy," Hari
said. "Acceding to it risks opening the barn door."
Venezuela, in particular, faces a mounting political crisis as
opposition leaders seek to oust President Nicolas Maduro, while
state-owned PDVSA sees its production at risk of collapsing due to
debt pressures and civil unrest.
Meanwhile, OPEC has invited several non-OPEC producers to the second
day of the technical meeting this week.
Russia has accepted the invitation, but OPEC officials have not
revealed which other countries will attend.
Russia has said it would prefer to freeze production at record-high
September levels of some 11.11 million b/d instead of cutting, but
has not committed to anything specific.
Market watchers say a Russian freeze at record levels would do
nothing to accelerate the rebalancing, and given the country's lack
of compliance with previous agreements with OPEC to curtail
production, many analysts remain dubious that Russia will provide
any meaningful cut.
"Without Russia on board, this deal will do little to support the
market in the short term as it leaves the risk wide open of another
major long liquidation phase, which in the past have moved the
market by up to 20%," Hansen said.
--Herman Wang,
herman.wang@spglobal.com
--Edited by Alisdair Bowles,
alisdair.bowles@spglobal.com
© 2016 Platts, The McGraw-Hill Companies Inc. All rights reserved.
To subscribe or visit go to:
http://www.platts.com
http://www.platts.com/latest-news/oil/london/opec-oil-output-freeze-negotiations-begin-in-26581339